The real record

Sajeeb Wazed, the prime minister’s son and emerging Awami League leader, is on record making what would appear to be extravagant claims and even more extravagant promises about the doubling of per capita income.

According to Channel I and Prothom Alo, Mr Wazed has said:

“In the past five years, your income has doubled. We promise that when we return to power, we will double it again … average income has increased from Tk40,000 to Tk80,000.”

The claim/promise has been relayed around the cyberspace, and is a key talking point in the Awami echo chamber. However, the Awami Leaguers would be well advised to not push this line.

Let’s go through this blow-by-blow.

Is it true that per capita income is now around Tk80,000?

Probably.

According to the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics’ official estimates, in 2012-13, the country’s per capita income was $923.

The official GDP is, however, based on a base year of 1995-96. As the economy is growing and evolving, it’s important to update the base year regularly. Just think about many goods and services that are commonplace now, but were not even thought of in 1995-96. In most countries, GDP bases are updated once every decade or so. BBS has been working on an updated GDP estimate, rebasing it to 2005-06.

Typically, when GDP base is updated, the entire size of the economy, and hence per capita income, rises for the simple reason that what was previously not counted is now counted. Not surprisingly, the new figures put per capita income somewhat higher than the previous figure – it’s now estimated to have been $1,044.

At Tk77 per dollar, per capita income was then somewhat higher than Tk80,000 in 2012-13. Cool.

Was it Tk40,000 when AL came into power?

Ah, this is where things get murky.

It turns out, the nominal GDP per capita, on the 1995-96 base, was around Tk42,600 in 2009.

Do note the two bits in bold.

Why is Mr Wazed using the 1995-96 base data for 2009 per capita income? Because BBS has not actually published the time series going back into history. As a leading English daily reports:

“The statistical agency, which last rebased in 2000, has got the nod of the technical committee and is now awaiting the green light from the government to start computing GDP using the 2005-06 base year, a senior official of the agency said, seeking to remain unnamed.”

Compared with 1995-96 base, the 2005-06 base will include agricultural products like “green banana, green papaya, green coconut, soybean, cucumber, hog plum, red amaranth, bottle gourd, olive, ripe palm, marigold, rose and tuberose,” construction items like “brick, wood and fixtures and fittings” and services like “motor vehicles repairing … the private airlines, clearing and forwarding and travel agents, internet service providers and cable operators.”

This will make for a more accurate estimate of the size, composition and evolution of the economy. This looks to be like sound, important work by the BBS. Presence of people like Prof Wahiduddin Mahmud does inspire confidence in the process.

But this is not a radical increase of the country’s GDP under this government. As the finance minister said:

“Usually, the GDP size increases under the new base year because of the addition of new elements in the economy. So, this change is nothing significant or unusual.”

Compared with the old estimate, GDP is 13% or so bigger in 2012-13 under the new estimate. And it’s reasonable to expect that when BBS finishes its rebasing, we will find that the economy was 13% bigger in 2009. That is, chances are nominal per capita income was not Tk40,000 in 2009 – it was more like Tk48,000.

Still, Tk48,000 rose to Tk80,000 – not double, but still a two-thirds increase during the current government’s term, that is, per capita income rising by roughly 13% a year for four years. This is surely an impressive achievement. If they could do this in the last term, surely they can be trusted to aim for 14% a year growth in the next term. And 14% a year growth for five years will mean per capita income will double.

Sure. But then again, per capita income also grew by around 13% a year under the 1/11 regime, over 9% a year under the last BNP government, and around 7% a year under both parties in the 1990s.

Wait a minute. Our per capita income has been growing by 7 to 13% a year for nearly a quarter century? How is this possible when economic growth has never reached 7%?

What’s going on here?

You see, when Mr Wazed said per capita income was Tk40,000 when AL came to power, he was referring to the nominal per capita income. Nominal income is measured in current prices – that is, there is no allowance for the increase in prices. And one does not need a Harvard course in economics to know that when it comes to comparing people’s welfare, what matters is real income – that is, income after accounting for inflation.

According to the BBS estimates (on 1995-96 base – remember, 2005-06 based data is not available yet), real GDP per capita has increased by 4.6% a year under this government, compared with 4.4% a year under the last BNP government. The same data suggests that under this government, inflation has been 7.3% a year, compared with 4.8% a year under the last BNP government.

I am sure the new data will change these figures slightly. But I don’t expect the broad pattern to change. Essentially, there are two macro facts when it comes to the economic record of this government and the last BNP government:

A. BNP did a much better job of controlling prices than this government has (Chart 1, left).

B. Even after accounting for inflation, per capita income has risen by around 4.5% under successive governments for over a decade now (Chart 1, right).

That’s an impressive record of per capita GDP growth. At this rate, real per capita income, and thus various indicators of health, education and other human welfare, will roughly double every 15 years. That is, our standard of living is roughly twice as high as was the case when Bangladesh first qualified for cricket world cup. And this is a collective effort, under successive governments.

Real GDP per capita

In FY2013, Bangladesh’s real GDP per capita was Tk67,600. This is measured in 2012-13 prices, but the estimated GDP is on the 1995-96 basis. As noted earlier, BBS is in the process of revising GDP estimates to be on 2005-06 basis. On that basis, the level of real GDP per capita is about 13% higher in FY2013 – that is, on that basis, per capita GDP in FY2013 was over Tk80,000.

But the detailed time series of GDP estimates on the 2005-06 basis is not available yet, so the analysis that follows in this series is done on the 1995-96 based GDP.

So, in FY2013, average Bangladeshi produced/earned Tk67,600. In FY2007 – the last year for which BNP government’s policies had immediate effect – real GDP per capita was Tk51,600. This might suggest that the average Bangladeshi is better off under the AL government. And in a simplistic way, it would be true. But it would also be almost as true as saying you are older under the AL government than you were under BNP.

You see, unless there is a natural disaster or political strife or severe recession, modern economies tend to grow every year, and thus at any point in time, real GDP per capita is expected to be higher than in the past. And as Chart 2 shows, real GDP per capita has been steadily increasing under successive governments over the past quarter century – the last year to record a fall in real GDP per capita was FY1988.

A better way to gauge performance is to look at the rate at which real GDP per capita – and since most measures of living standards are its correlates, most other data series we will encounter in this series – is changing over time.

Chart 3 compares annual average growth in real GDP per capita under various governments in the past three decades – Mujib and Zia/Sattar governments are excluded from comparison because the effects of the Liberation War and aftermath make them difficult to compare with the more recent governments. As the chart shows, under the second Khaleda government (six years to FY2007), real GDP per capita grew by 4.43% a year, compared with 4.60% a year under the second Hasina government (four years to FY2013). For the sake of completeness, under the 1/11 regime, real GDP per capita grew by 6.62%.

At this point, let me stress that these numbers are estimates, which are regularly revised. Therefore, it is very important that we don’t get too hung up on second decimal point differences. The macroeconomic fact is, in the last decade, under all three governments, per capita GDP has grown by around 4.5% a year. At that rate, average real (that is, inflation-adjusted) income doubles in 16 years. That is, should this rate continue for another couple of years, by the middle of the next government’s term, the average Bangladeshi will have a standard of living that is double what he or she experienced at the turn of the millennium.

This is impressive stuff, for which every recent government deserves some credit. Note the qualifier “some” – could it be that the recent growth in GDP per capita has nothing to do with our governments? Maybe average incomes have grown despite the governments? Maybe we just have been extremely lucky in the past decade?

Well, we can perhaps knock out the luck factor – we saw natural disasters like floods as well as adverse economic shocks like global food price inflation or the great recession in the past decade, so it’s not clear to me that we have been lucky in recent years. And in fact, as I have argued elsewhere, reforms implemented by Saifur Rahman in the early 1990s, and sustained by SAMS Kibria in the late 1990s, have a lot to do with the more recent performance.

But exactly how much credit should accrue to which government would require much more detailed analysis. For now, the point to note is, when it comes to growth in average income, there isn’t much difference between the three latest governments.