History repeats itself a cliché if there ever was one. Funky scriptures, heavy tomes, and dusty documents, these are the inhabitants of historical archives. Rarely do they ever have visitors other than the keenest of aficionados the only people who deliberately stay connected with our past. What if that changed? What if, suddenly, everybody paid attention? What if our present forced us to look back into our past? Now that’s all well and good if we are reliving glories, but seldom do we have that luxury.
March 20, 2003. Does that date mean anything to you? No? Well it does to more than 20,000 Iraqi families who lost members to a senseless farce. This was the day on which the Iraq war began. Only a decade has passed since then, even though it seems like eons. These perceived eons have eroded the war’s significance to us the non-victims, at least.
I just switched off my television with an overwhelming sense of deja-vu; everything was the same back then. Closed-door meetings, staunch positions, suspect assertions, and disregarded anti-war protests. The world’s recollection may be sketchy, but it has been here before.
Let us juxtapose the past and the present, shall we? Prior to the Iraq war, claims that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMD) became overwhelming. This translated to a security threat for regional/coalition allies and Iraq itself. In 2002, United Nations Monitoring, Verification, and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC) requested Iraqi cooperation on a probe conducted by UN inspectors.
Preceding the war, no evidence of WMD was found and investigators continuously stressed that their work was still unfinished they needed months of further verification. Sadly, they were never given these months. Fast forward a decade and we can’t help but gawk at the similarity of the situation in Syria, which mimics what we thought was buried and beyond exhumation.
If anything, circumstances are worse this time around the Syrian civil-war is sanguinary enough as it is. Governed by an internationally denounced regime and infested with insurgents, Syria is a murky diplomatic chessboard of black, white and fifty shades of grey. Contradictory reports, disagreeing super powers, an absence of details, and obscurity in their presence make Syria even more convoluted than Iraq was.
As I write this, UN investigators are examining whether chemical weapons were used in Syria. Pardon me if I offend you, but this strikes me as a pathetic waste of time. It is evident that chemical weapons were used in Syria and the only real question is by whom? The authorities have stated that the ongoing investigation will not assign blame to anyone; it will only pointlessly re-evaluate whether chemical weapons were used.
Back in 2003, UN investigators were cautioned to leave Iraq, a mere four days before the military invasion began. The investigators’ work, which represented further months of waiting, was unceremoniously truncated. We have been told that the Syrian situation is imminent, just like the Iraqi situation was imminent. If that is true, then the Syrian investigation may not be waited upon. Although, it is highly unlikely that such a narrow investigation will accomplish anything, even if it is waited for.
The world is looking for a quick answer. The question is “Who did it?” Every moment lost in a futile investigation which simply will not answer this question is a moment closer to war. The number of countries which have volunteered to support military action against Syria is already in the double digits. War is impending; we must hurry.
In a recent interview, Bashar Al-Asaad was straight forward. He warned the United States to expect “every action” in response to a strike on Syria fighting words indeed. If this is anything to go by, then the Syrian people haven’t seen the worst of their woes yet. From the other side, we have received repeated reassurances of a “limited, narrow,” “unbelievably small,” attack. These comforts have been skeptically received, to say the least.
What makes this attack so necessary? The math is more complicated than high school calculus. A simplified version of the argument is anchored on neutralising a “potential” weapons threat on the region, on Europe, and on the United States. Eerily redolent of Iraq, isn’t it? It evokes rightful fears. Syria could become the “new” Iraq.
Chemical weapons have been used lifeless bodies and post-mortem reports prove this but by whom? How big is the stockpile of these weapons? Was August 21, 2013 an isolated event? Or will we have to watch hundreds being silenced by sarin, once again? And most importantly who was responsible?
I realise quite indifferently that I have been repetitive in my use of “who,” but this is a question that must be answered. Without this obligatory answer, war would be sheer insanity. This however, is not to say that decisive, transparent, and incriminating proof would justify a war of any sort. War without proof will be irrational and with it, immoral. War isn’t an option in a civilised world. It never can be. What does that tell you about the world we live in?
The Obama administration and its allies have pointed to Syria and reiterated rightfully the need to follow international regulations and norms. However, where does their credibility go when they themselves make the world expect a war instead of a diplomatic solution? That too, a war that allegedly doesn’t need to be sanctioned by the UN Security Council.
A civil-war is domestic by definition and external interference should be condemned unless it is absolutely necessary. Is it necessary now? Is it really? Was it necessary in Iraq? WMD were never found in Iraq and that is a disgrace that mustn’t be repeated. The Iraq war was a waste of money, energy, and lives. If the war on Syria commences, no matter how “small” the attack, it will be evident that Iraq has taught us nothing.
Reports and pictures released to the public prove beyond the shadow of a doubt that something is wrong. Graphic videos of people foaming at the mouth, gasping for their last breaths, tell us that chemical weapons were definitely used in Syria. By whom and to what objective might never be discovered. Under these circumstances, the notions of a security threat are highly credible. However, this assertion, credible as it may be, true or false, will never justify war.
There is a faction of anti-war conspiracy theorists out there and I am not one of them. I am not interested in the diplomatic chess game that is unfolding behind the scenes, nor do I care for the ulterior motivations behind an attack or even a non-attack. The only thing that concerns me is the fate of the fellow human beings whose lives will be uprooted, should a war begin. Refugee camp populations will explode and a split country will be shattered.
Syria’s situation now and Iraq’s back then are so similar that it is hard not to think of Iraq as a crystal ball revealing Syria’s future. The Iraq war lasted eight years, eight months, three weeks and four days. It killed more than a hundred thousand people and injured almost thrice as many. It paralysed a country and left it worse than it was a decade ago. War was not a solution in Iraq and it certainly is not in Syria.
The Syrian political system is supremely volatile and any direct external action would push it past a fatal tipping point. The world witnessed, in horror, the brutality with which Syrian rebels executed seven Assad loyalists. The balance is delicate. Bombing Syrian chemical weapons depots will contaminate the surroundings and put these weapons in the hands of rogue militia, who will use them even more unpredictably.
A power struggle as dramatic as Syria’s needs no additional condiments. Diplomacy is the only option. Recent conversation table breakthroughs offer a glimmer of hope we may yet tread down a pacifistic path.
Leaders of religious minority communities in Syria are begging the United States to avoid a strike at any cost. They are afraid, and their fears are vindicated by the religious violence Iraq experienced post-invasion. Even Pope Francis has tried to weigh in on the G20 leaders, calling a military solution “futile.” Military action has a history of failure in situations which would have been better handled diplomatically.
Failure in Syria would mean a perpetual insurgency and a proliferation of the terrorist element in this bedlam, neither of which are goals for the international community. Regarding the Iraq war, the former director of United States central intelligence, George J Tenet, stated that Bush administration pushed the country to war in Iraq without ever conducting a “serious debate” about whether Saddam Hussein was an imminent threat to the United States.
A similar dilemma faces world leaders today. We must act by what Iraq has taught us. This is not a time for haste; it is a time for open-minded negotiation. History doesn’t repeat itself; it’s we who repeat it, by repeating mistakes.
As I draw to a close, I should address the futility of this article. What do I hope to achieve by it? Frankly, nothing. Spectators like me must wait and watch. A friend once told me that we must walk with our heads held high, as if the earth is ours; as if an ancestor of enormous wealth died and bequeathed the whole world to us.
The world is mine as much as it is yours and I find something fundamentally wrong with a world where blood is spilled and lives jeopardised needlessly and at the hands of something avoidable. The best we can do is watch. As global citizens, we must.
Diplomats shall dance and we shall scrutinise. Who’s missing steps? Who stomped on whose toes? The corresponding answers will not solve this crisis, but at least they will illuminate the heroes and the villains of this drama. We must watch, knowing that it will not make a difference. We must condemn this violence for the sake of it. Beyond that, all we can do is hope.
War never dies. The freedom fighters of ’71 are testament. The scars, physical and mental, live on. Nevertheless, for every war that begins, there comes a day when it officially ends. For Iraq that day was December 15, 2011. For Syria, I hope the war never ends, because a war that never starts, never can.