CSR does not mean charity

Many senior figures in civil society, regulatory bodies and universities might be shocked to hear corporate social responsibility (CSR) has nothing or very little to do with charity. I know, it is very tough for them to accept that money diverted or donated from state owned and private commercial banks to buy furniture, computers, microbuses and refurbishing the teachers’ lounge in Dhaka University can not accurately be labelled under CSR.

Giving scholarships to poor, meritorious students is very worthy but this is charity, not CSR. Helping a destitute woman with medical treatment is a very good job, but this is again charity. Similarly, the assistance provided to schools and under other humanitarian angles can’t be tallied as CSR.

Yes, Bangladesh Police needs many vehicles to run to the accident site promptly. Maybe the Rapid Action Battalion needed their canteen to be refurbished; there’s nothing wrong in supporting these activities. Nothing wrong either with banks or financial institutions coming forward to help a Tagore song competition or mobile companies to support Sabina Yasmeen or Runa Laila or any ill or disadvantaged artists. But again this is charity not CSR.

Many in the corporate world need to know there is a great myth about the buzzwords associated with CSR. The leading British weekly the Economist ran an opinion poll on the subject for several weeks which reconfirms there is a “disconnect” between understandings of CSR and charity.

We often get confused with charity versus CSR and label purely philanthropic activities in the name of CSR. The concept of CSR is not just social; there is a lot more to it than just corporate philanthropy.

Today corporate social responsibility goes far beyond basic charitable activities of the past. It is not just about making a contribution towards good causes but is instead an all-year-round responsibility that acknowledges companies should serve the community, its business, workers, customers and other stakeholders.

CSR must integrate with corporate values, culture and the company’s strategy to achieve future sustainability. This is more like “people were hungry in the past, people are hungry at present, but instead of giving them a bread for today, teach them or help them to eradicate poverty.” It is more than giving away charitable items through “Zakat.” It is ensuring the Zakat money enables a person to not require Zakat the next time, because he or she has already become capable to generate income through the money given to him or her in the past.

The profit that each institution makes should reflect its core values and adhere to best practices. Thus, CSR is in fact more than just a company engaging in charity in its local community. It is the recognition that brand names depend not only on quality, price and uniqueness but on how, cumulatively, they interact with companies’ workforce, community, environment and, moreover, run their businesses.

The results of a company are judged not only by the input but also by its outcomes: the difference we make to the world in which we operate, and the contribution we make for sustainable development, as mentioned above.

It is an ambitious vision that CSR in its modern sense requires a business to operate responsibly taking into account their economic, social and environmental impacts, and to act to address their key sustainable development challenges.

But a major controversy still lies in the true understanding of CSR. If we look ten to twenty years back, CSR was just a jargon for most people and was not given so much of importance. Now we feel CSR is a business reality and any company, which enjoys privileges granted by the society, must be socially responsible and accountable.

We see CSR as businesses’ contribution to society and sustainable development. There are many definitions but they all relate to how business takes account of its economic, social and environmental impacts in the way it operates, maximising the benefits and minimising the downsides.

I am not talking about mere philanthropy. CSR has to be good for long-term business success as well as for the wider society in order to move forward to the next trajectory.

CSR also often calls for finding a niche as an ethical organisation. To translate this into a business perspective, how can competitive advantage be created, through approaches to CSR or even niche product development? Successful innovation will come from looking ahead to environmental and social trends and planning to create opportunities in that new environment.

To spot a future niche, a business has to be a constant trend-watcher, alert to its environment, ready to spot the product-client mix to which it is uniquely adapted. The true sense of CSR will also address the meaning of “survival of the fittest” for a business. Thinking about how organisations evolve, how adaptation enables “survival of the fittest” has long been an analogy that has helped business strategists.

Can it really be simply fitness to eliminate all competitors in your path? Increasingly, it is becoming important to measure success through working in partnerships with different stakeholders.

As mentioned above, and possibly engrained in the “upper chamber” of many in Bangladesh is the defining of CSR in most cases to be a part of charity. But it is in fact the reverse. Charity can be an important part of CSR, which signifies a corporation’s contribution to the community where it does business. But CSR of a company involves a lot of factors that we usually tend to overlook. CSR is a much bigger picture when a company voluntarily integrates a complete range of economic, social, and environmental concerns in its business and communication with its stakeholders.

Again many companies have different concepts to serving the community. It can be a part of CSR or a part of corporate citizenship. For many big companies, all these initiatives are a commitment to being a responsible corporate citizen and an industry partner working with businesses, communities and governments to help advance economic and social well being and to enable people around the world to realise their full potential.

Corporate governance also goes side by side with CSR: how a company acts within a set regulatory structure and how companies manage their business processes to produce an overall positive impact on society. Corporate social responsibility and social reporting is corporate governance in action.

CSR for a company involves a total dedication and a shared responsibility to clients, to each other and to the franchise: whether a company is doing a business in a responsible way or whether they are perceived as a responsible corporate citizen, not only to their clients but also how they are eyed by the regulators and all the relevant stakeholders; whether a company is supporting the country’s vision for overall economic and social development; whether the company is attacking the right cause in the name of charity.

We may often find that a company may not have a CSR policy and even if it does, there will be different opinions about the definition of CSR. The majority of companies do not meet the criteria of a planned CSR model, although they do practice charity. Charity and CSR are related but different concepts.

In other words, CSR is just as much a way of thinking about and doing business. And that way of thinking needs to be brought to the mainstream across business operations and into company strategy. It is not just a task for the public relations department but needs to permeate across the company: in business development, marketing, human resources, finance and so on. I believe this is being reflected in the growing consensus that such integration is the only way for CSR to realise its full potential.

In a nutshell, CSR has continued to be a highly topical and debated subject. It has increasingly provided the focus for exploration of broad philosophical questions about the roles and responsibilities of companies and their relationship with the roles and responsibilities of government and other stakeholders.

But it has also provided the context for debate on more particular questions from donating to a charity to employee volunteering, to poverty eradication, and many more. Does this mean that CSR risks being about everything and nothing?

Although debates about CSR have continued to grow, we remain a long way from consensus on what it means and what its value is. We often conclude that it is just about glossy reports and public relations. Some see it as a source of business opportunity and improved competitiveness. Others see it as a distraction or threat. But is there any particular framework for a planned CSR?

Very often, the relationship between CSR and a company’s core business seems to depend largely on the views of the CEO and the chairman. There are still companies that conduct CSR by just donating money. However, many organisations are contributing to society by donating their own unique knowledge, know-how and resources.

The main differences between large corporations and medium-sized and small ones lie in the method chosen for CSR and the underlying motives. CSR is often not publicly communicated; there may be some very interesting underlying business concepts.

But clearly the ways that individual companies take up the challenge of CSR must reflect their particular circumstances. The approach, challenges and opportunities will naturally be very different among different local and multinational companies.

For many companies the focus is on “doing” CSR rather than reporting on it. CSR has continued to develop well beyond its philanthropic and community roots with a growing focus on the business case, making the business a socially responsible one and of course in standing out from the crowd by serving the core values of the society in which the corporation works.

By integrating CSR into the way we do business, I believe companies can be part of the solution to some of these challenges. But we need to look at how we can encourage businesses to make CSR activities part of their core business and make it an approach that makes a real difference in the society.

The bottom line is that CSR is a combination of a company’s initiatives which integrates its views and actions towards social and environmental concerns where the business operates, whilst taking into account the interaction with all relevant stakeholders.

Charity is part of the picture and should and will always be there as the need for philanthropy will not go away. Rich people should and must help the poor.

In this part of the world we have seen many zamindars (landlords) and monarchs put up many schools and colleges, despite controversies regarding the “how” part of where they got or made their money.

Most of the zamindars in Bangladesh were very keen to build mosques or help the destitute. Though most of these activities carry significant historic importance, they could not work cohesively to take our community, society or country forward.

In today’s world we need more responsible entrepreneurs, business houses and corporations to be integrated in the development process in a more concrete and responsible manner. We want them committed to our possible future. In a dynamic and shifting world, we need to go beyond the boxes to redefine many of the already defined or even resolved issues or subjects.