George Orwell famously wrote in Politics and the English Language (1946) that "political language is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind."
Decades before social media and the proliferation of disinformation, Orwell understood that political legitimacy is both shaped and justified through media, often manipulated by compliant intellectuals and partisan outlets. Central to this process is language -- used not to illuminate reality but to obscure it, turning falsehoods into accepted truths and vice versa.
In Bangladesh, which recently emerged from a brutal 15-year autocracy, prominent intellectuals played a critical role in this endeavour. Their social credibility lent weight to their words, making their defenses of corrupt rulers particularly effective. By endorsing official narratives, they legitimized deceit and facilitated impunity for state-sanctioned violence, including extrajudicial killings and enforced disappearances.
Orwell’s literary allegories: Animal Farm and 1984
Orwell explored the complicity of intellectuals in authoritarian regimes in two satirical masterpieces: Animal Farm and 1984. Though his primary focus was Stalinist totalitarianism, his insights apply to autocratic regimes worldwide, including in Bangladesh.
In Animal Farm, Orwell tells the story of an uprising through the lens of animals uniting to overthrow their human oppressors. Initially, the revolution promises equality, but power soon consolidates under a new ruler from among their own, establishing a new authoritarian elite class. While the new ruling pig schemes to eliminate his rivals and establish absolute control, another propagandist pig, Squealer, plays an essential role in manipulating language to justify Napoleon’s actions, distort history, and suppress dissent.
1984 expands on this theme through the Ministry of Truth, which systematically rewrites history to serve the regime’s interests. Squealer, in this sense, is a prototype for the bureaucrats and intellectuals who sustain autocracies by reshaping public perception through calculated rhetoric.
The role of intellectuals in sustaining autocracy: The Bangladesh parallel
Autocratic regimes rely on more than brute force; they depend on an ecosystem of enablers, including academics, journalists, and cultural figures. These individuals, though unarmed, wield influence that is often more insidious than that of state security forces. Through their writings, speeches, and media appearances, they rationalize government policies, discredit opposition voices, and present authoritarian rule as a necessary or even benevolent force. This intellectual scaffolding reinforces the regime’s power, making oppression appear palatable or even justified.
The mechanisms of control Orwell described have been evident in Bangladesh’s political landscape. During Sheikh Hasina’s 15-year rule, a cohort of intellectuals, much like Squealer, tirelessly defended the regime’s actions, crafting a narrative of economic progress and stability to justify political repression and institutional corruption.
In the final days of Hasina’s rule, the alignment of certain intellectuals with the government became particularly evident. Prominent journalists and media leaders pledged unwavering support, while leading academics dismissed student-led protests as conspiratorial threats. Even as state violence escalated -- civilians gunned down in the streets, government forces targeting protesters with impunity -- these individuals remained silent or actively defended the administration.
Understanding intellectual complicity
Noam Chomsky has argued that intellectuals bear a moral duty to challenge power and reveal the truth. Yet, many do the opposite, actively suppressing truth or manufacturing alternative narratives in service of the ruling elite. Why do intellectuals, who should serve as society’s conscience, instead become accomplices to authoritarianism?
Three key motivations stand out: Material gain, fear, and ideological loyalty.
The lure of material benefits is easy to understand. Prestigious government positions (such as university vice-chancellors or ambassadorial roles abroad), cheap government land, or at the very least, free foreign trips with the head of state -- many of us personally know individuals who have enjoyed such perks.
Autocratic regimes rely on more than brute force; they depend on an ecosystem of enablers, including academics, journalists, and cultural figures
Our experience in Bangladesh with such people is too well known. We have seen them at press conferences, nervously wringing their hands and addressing the leader as "honourable leader" a dozen times over. Yet, in private conversations, they expressed different opinions. However, once someone benefits from tyranny, it becomes difficult to change their stance.
Fear is also a compelling factor. In Stalin’s Soviet Union or Hitler’s Germany, there were countless examples of people losing their lives simply for opposing tyranny. Extraordinary writers and thinkers like Nikolai Bukharin and Isaac Babel were executed solely for their political views. Nobel Peace Prize winner Carl von Ossietzky was left to starve to death in Hitler’s concentration camps. Philosopher Walter Benjamin, unable to escape, took his own life.
Thus, fear of physical persecution makes collaboration with tyranny unsurprising. In Bangladesh in 1971, for this very reason, despite their deep-seated hatred for military rule, some people wrote columns in favour of the military takeover or participated in radio and television discussions.
However, philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre would argue that even in the harshest times, collaboration -- or in plain terms, servility -- is not the only option for intellectuals or for any citizen. Man is born free, Sartre said -- "Man is condemned to be free" -- and he is compelled to make choices.
Every decision carries responsibility. When a person submits to tyranny, it is also an exercise of his freedom. But to claim that servility is the only choice is unacceptable because the alternative -- resistance -- is always available. Some choose prison, some choose exile, and some, like the poet Mayakovsky, choose suicide. All these are expressions of individual free will.
While Bangladesh’s tyranny may not have been as ruthless or efficient as Stalin’s or Hitler’s, it had no shortage of oppressive tools. We have heard of "Aynaghar" (the torture chambers). We know about Harun’s DB office. Cases of enforced disappearances and extrajudicial killings are not rare.
Fear compels some to side with tyranny out of necessity, and we should not hesitate to acknowledge this. But there are also many who chose servility not out of fear but for a "good life" -- a little extra money in their pockets, a few TV appearances per month, or at the very least, the opportunity to drink at Dhaka Club on someone else’s tab.
The case of ideological loyalty
The third factor is ideological loyalty. No doubt, some people collaborate with tyranny out of deep ideological belief. Many sincerely believe that working with an authoritarian regime serves a greater cause.
Earlier, I mentioned Nikolai Bukharin, a devoted believer in the Russian Revolution who remained silent even when falsely accused of being a foreign agent because he feared that criticizing Stalin would damage the revolution.
Or consider the case of Argentine writer Julio Cortázar. Before Gabriel García Márquez, he experimented with "magical realism," giving the world this distinctive literary genre. He was a staunch supporter of Cuba’s socialist revolution. Despite having evidence that his close friends were persecuted under Fidel Castro, he remained loyal to the revolution.
In 1971, renowned Cuban writer Heberto Padilla was arrested for anti-revolutionary poetry and statements. Many Western intellectuals, who had once supported the Cuban revolution, criticized the Castro government. But Cortázar refused to change his stance. At the time, he said, "No matter how much doubt or concern I may have, I will never abandon my belief in the Cuban revolution. No revolution is perfect, but resisting imperialism is more important than purity."
When a person submits to tyranny, it is also an exercise of his freedom. But to claim that servility is the only choice is unacceptable because the alternative -- resistance -- is always available
The ideological loyalty of Bangladeshi intellectuals
A section of Bangladeshi intellectuals has always stood with the people, resisting military and civilian misrule. The 1952 Language Movement, which was essentially a protest against Pakistani dictatorship, was led by students, teachers, and intellectuals.
In 1961, when the East Pakistan government attempted to ban Rabindranath Tagore’s works, intellectuals led a nationwide movement against it.
Even after independence, during Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s rule, distinguished writers and intellectuals like Shamsur Rahman, Anisuzzaman, Ahmed Sharif, and Abdul Gaffar Chowdhury opposed his proposed one-party rule. Some of them were close to Mujib and believed in his ideals, yet they had the moral courage to reject his political agenda. This is why we still respect them.
So why have a large number -- perhaps the majority -- of Bangladesh’s intellectuals not only accepted but also actively supported Sheikh Hasina’s authoritarian rule over the past decade and a half?
For many pro-government intellectuals, financial benefits and fear were likely the main reasons for aligning with tyranny. However, outside of these opportunists, there were also many intellectuals who remained loyal to Hasina’s government purely for ideological reasons.
We know many such figures -- people who did not receive any tangible personal benefits from the regime. They were not fools; they knew very well that Hasina’s government was openly autocratic and corrupt, solely focused on maintaining dynastic control through an oligarchy. Yet, they consciously supported its authoritarian misrule out of the belief that there was no alternative to Hasina in preserving the spirit of the Liberation War and preventing religious extremism.
I have met many people who continue to believe the fall of the Hasina regime would usher in fundamentalism and result in the loss of the values of the 1971 Liberation War. I do think they are sincere in their conviction, desperately clinging to a tyrannical regime out of a deep loyalty to the spirit of 1971.
Yet I feel nothing but pity for such intellectuals. They witnessed firsthand how the previous government trampled upon all the values of the Liberation War. Freedom of speech was crushed, voting rights were stripped away, and every institution, from the judiciary to law enforcement, from education to the economy, was dismantled. Countless people were imprisoned simply for holding different political views.
None of this was done in secret -- it was all out in the open. And yet, when intellectuals, out of devotion to their preferred ideology, become the shield of tyranny, what else can one do but pity them?
Life not worth living
One of my intellectual heroes is Václav Havel, the moral conscience of Czechoslovakia. Imprisoned repeatedly for his defiance of tyranny, he embodied the true role of an intellectual. He once declared, "An intellectual is someone who bears witness to all the suffering of the world, who opposes all forms of compromise, who speaks out against every hidden pressure and deception, who is the first to question and challenge those in power."
Regrettably, many of our intellectuals have failed to meet the standard Havel set, choosing silence or complicity over courage and truth. They lived a life not worth living.
Hasan Ferdous is an author and journalist based in New York.