A pyramid of schemes

As George Orwell once penned in Animal Farm: “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” It’s a sentiment that rings hauntingly true in Bangladesh, where the nation’s public administration morphed into a bureaucratic battleground over the years, and equality -- much like Orwell’s farm -- is little more than a whispered illusion. What was once a neatly structured system, designed to serve the people, has become a chaotic, politically-charged pyramid, with too many bureaucrats pushing for position at the top, and too few willing to do the work at the bottom.

Take, for instance, the peculiar case of Bangladesh’s public administration, where the pyramid metaphor feels more like a bureaucratic balancing act gone wrong. At the bottom are the foot soldiers, the officers who have spent years diligently climbing the ladder, believing that merit and service would lead to eventual promotion. At the top? An army of additional secretaries, joint secretaries, and senior secretaries, swelling in numbers far beyond what is necessary or logical, promoted not by merit but by their proximity to the political throne.

And what a throne it was. For nearly two decades, the Awami League ruled Bangladesh with an iron fist, ensuring that loyalty to the party was rewarded with promotions aplenty. Forget the pyramids of Egypt -- Bangladesh’s public administration is starting to resemble the Tower of Babel, a structure so overburdened with politically-motivated appointments that it’s no wonder the whole thing has been teetering on collapse.

When everyone’s a secretary

Imagine a situation where your job title is supposed to mean something, but instead, it’s handed out like candy. A senior secretary in Bangladesh used to be a prestigious position, the reward for decades of service. But now? Well, if everyone’s a senior secretary, is anyone?

Take a look at the numbers. Under the Awami League’s rule, the number of secretaries ballooned from 60 to 82. The number of additional secretaries? More than doubled, with over 546 individuals now holding that title. And joint secretaries? Well, why stop at doubling when you can triple the number, with over 1,100 individuals jostling for space in a role meant for 500.

It’s as though someone in charge forgot the meaning of “pyramid” altogether. This structure now looks more like a bloated balloon, overinflated and ready to burst at any moment.

But the promotions, it seems, were not merely about filling positions. They were strategic moves, carefully orchestrated to keep certain loyalists happy, while others -- those inconveniently qualified but politically neutral -- languished without recognition. Like a poorly written Shakespearean tragedy, the stage was set for chaos, and chaos, indeed, has come.

When merit is but a dream

If you are one of the lucky few who believed that working hard, keeping your head down, and waiting for the right time would eventually pay off, you’re probably sitting at your desk right now, shaking your head in disbelief. In this topsy-turvy world, merit has become the casualty, left to rot under the weight of nepotism, favoritism, and, of course, political gamesmanship.

"Promotion in Bangladesh’s public administration has become more of a political handshake than a reward for merit," quips one disgruntled official, who, unsurprisingly, prefers to remain anonymous. "It’s not about what you’ve done, it’s about who you know -- and how loudly you can cheer for the right team."

The result? A massive group of "officers on special duty" -- officials who have been promoted to prestigious posts but find themselves with little to no actual work. A whole army of bureaucrats collecting salaries, allowances, and perks, while being told to sit quietly and wait for further instructions. It’s like being handed a crown, only to find out that it’s made of plastic.

When bureaucrats attack

The chaos doesn’t stop at promotions. With the rise of the interim government, led by Nobel laureate Professor Muhammad Yunus, the simmering frustration of those bypassed for years is now boiling over. Dissatisfied officers are staging protests, demanding promotions they believe are long overdue. Fights have even broken out in the hallowed halls of the Secretariat itself, a place once known for quiet efficiency.

Who needs an action movie when you’ve got bureaucrats fighting for promotions? It’s an absurd reality --  government officials, those supposed to uphold the integrity of the state, backbiting like school-children over who gets to be the teacher’s pet. The very officials who were promoted under the Awami League’s rule, now finding themselves sidelined by the new regime, are refusing to cooperate. The result is a government that moves as sluggishly as a bureaucratic dinosaur, with files piling up and decisions left pending.

Cleaning up a political mess

And so, the interim government finds itself stuck between a rock and a hard place. How do you deal with a bloated administration where meritocracy has been sacrificed at the altar of political loyalty? Professor Yunus, renowned for his expertise in economics and social change, now faces the unenviable task of untangling this bureaucratic knot. But like trying to clean up after a tornado, the damage done by years of politically-motivated appointments is going to be hard to undo, even more so overnight.

It’s as if the Awami League left behind a ticking time bomb, one filled with unhappy officials, unnecessary promotions, and, of course, a hefty bill. The sheer cost of maintaining this overstuffed bureaucracy is shocking. Salaries, allowances, housing -- each unnecessary promotion comes with a price tag that’s ultimately paid by the tax-payer.

Over the last decade, government spending on salaries and allowances has more than doubled, going from around Tk28,000 crore to over Tk81,000cr. But while the pyramid continues to inflate, the actual work of the government grinds to a halt. For all the titles being handed out, very little is getting done. The bureaucratic engine is sputtering, weighed down by the sheer number of officers who have titles but no real responsibilities.

Will the pyramid collapse?

The question now is whether this pyramid of chaos can be salvaged, or whether it will collapse under its own weight. The interim government has set up a commission, led by Abdul Mueed Chowdhury, to address the issue. Their task? To bring order to this bureaucratic madness, to root out corruption, and to create a merit-based system that can serve the people of Bangladesh rather than the whims of politicians.

But as any student of Orwell knows, once a system is built on favoritism and cronyism, it is hard to dismantle it without a fight. The chickens have come home to roost, and they’re making quite a mess of things.

In the end, Bangladesh’s bloated bureaucracy is a cautionary tale -- a reminder that when politics infects every corner of public administration, the result is a system that works for the few, not the many. The interim government’s reforms may be a step in the right direction, but one has to wonder: Can a pyramid built on political loyalty ever truly be reshaped into one based on merit? Or will it simply continue to grow, bloated and unwieldy, until it finally collapses under the weight of its own absurdity?

 

HM Nazmul Alam, Lecturer, Department of English and Modern Languages, International University of Business, Agriculture and Technology.