Remember, remember …

There’s a specter haunting Bangladesh -- the specter of rage and discontent. Under the current administration, this specter reared its head for the first time back in 2018 (not just once, but twice). The first time, students were angry over the unfair quota advantages baked into government jobs. The second time, the catalyst was the failure to enforce functional road safety rules and regulations -- a situation that led to the death of a university student. 

In such instances, the authorities have always seemed to make the wrong move. Instead of trying to find peaceful, sustainable solutions to these issues, the authorities have always unleashed even more police along with the BCL, Jubo League, you get the picture (allegedly of course). The rumour mill went into overdrive.

But this time, these unspeakable acts weren’t confined to just rumours. This time, these unspeakable acts turned out to be the cold, verifiable truth. 

When news first broke of one Abu Sayed dying due to no fault of his own, I initially believed it was a rumour. Who knows, maybe part of me wanted to believe that. 

In 2019, students of BUET protested the killing of one Abrar Fahad at the hands of the BCL, and although they were able to get the killers condemned to the gallows and outlaw all kinds of student politics from the campus (BCL especially), BCL has been slowly but surely working on re-capturing BUET. 

There was another protest at SUST in 2022 (I forget how it started) where inevitably the authorities made promises of meeting the student’s demands (after beating them, of course. Spare the rod, spoil the child), but if I’m not wrong, not much progress has been made on that front as well.

Even now, even after so much blood has been spilled (because Abu Sayed was only the first in a long line of victims claimed. Once again, we saw more police, more BCL members, and even calling in the military. 

Fair enough, a part of me says. Dhaka is in a state of anarchy and in such states, you have to show some muscle. I get that. But what I don’t get is why such muscle couldn’t simply be stationed some distance away from the protesters to make sure that things wouldn’t escalate. What I don’t get is why such muscle couldn’t simply be content with making sure that criminal elements were unable to infiltrate the students protests. 

On July 18, 2024, this “muscle” brutalized the students of Brac University to the point where they had to retreat within their own campus. Even then, the police allegedly wouldn’t stop shooting at them. When people from other parts of Dhaka tried to take some much needed medical /other supplies to the university, they were allegedly denied entry. When ambulances tried to enter the university premises to take care of the wounded, they were allegedly denied entry as well (at the start at least). 

I guess the final nail in the coffin for that assault was the alleged video of a police car running over protesters (Since the internet blackout, the police have allegedly fired at people en masse, something that is backed up by the official death count. Allegedly of course. And if you are as tired of reading the word “allegedly” over and over as I am as tired of writing it…there was once a cartoonist called Kishore. Remember him. Remember him well). 

As for what followed, well … the internet is back but barely (after being out for days). There’s a curfew in place that’s seemingly set up to go on for the foresseable future. There’s a rumour that the police are raiding people’s houses, checking their phones for anything inflammatory, and making prompt arrests. One of the student leaders that spearheaded the movement claimed to have been abducted and coerced to make peace with the government. 

So far, there have been thousands of arrests and counting (Tens of thousands have been accused in different cases. The official position is that all those that have been detained (and killed) are terrorists who are members of BNP and Jamaat. To that I say, well … you have eyes and ears, right? (And surely even people of parties such as BNP and Jamaat deserve justice? No one should be punished simply for their political ideologies).

A democratic country should never have to resort to such tactics. A democratic country should have been able to navigate a sticky situation effectively without it turning into total chaos (the authorities only deigned to sit down with the students and listen to their demands after the death tally reached double digits. Why wasn’t this done from the beginning? Why was the situation allowed to go on in the way it did?). 

When news first broke of one Abu Sayed dying due to no fault of his own, I initially believed it was a rumour

So yes, the authorities could have done much better when it comes to the current protests. But I think there’s one big difference between their retaliation now and all the retaliations of the past. I think there’s more to the authorities’ bringing out the big guns. The authorities know that things are on the verge of turning bad for them -- and this makes them uneasy. This uneasiness made them double down on the people, but in doing so, they have made one crucial mistake. They have pushed people to their limits.

Because this is the first time in over a long, long time that people have lost their loved ones, have learned how it feels to lose blood. If the history of the world (along with our own history, might I add) teaches us anything, it is that when people learn to lose blood, they suddenly become emboldened to lose much more. 

And all of this has happened because the authorities failed to protect the masses. Therefore, given the seriousness of the situation, here are somethings that the authorities should do:

  1. They need to keep their temper in check. This means that if something like this happens again in the future it might not be the best idea to reactively retaliate with the police, the BCL, etc on innocent protesters. Instead, the authorities need to listen. This whole bloodbath could have been avoided if they had just listened. 
  2. Proper investigation of all of the deaths has to be carried out. Again, if we look at Abu Sayed, the video shows him simply standing in front of the police as a barricade. No violence, no shenanigans -- just a young man standing in front of the police in order to protect his fellow students. He was shot from barely 60-70 feet away, and he was shot twice. 

This is a clear case of police brutality. As such, thorough investigations have to be made, the culprits must be brought to justice, and the entire law-enforcement wing needs to be restructured (because a law-enforcement wing that knows only to resort to violence in times of crisis is not fit for purpose).  

  1. They need to lay off such tactics such as closing universities and forcing VCs into allowing police into campuses, a tactic that is especially designed to brutalize students into submission (the VCs and other university-affiliated officials who have allowed such things to happen -- not only now but in the past as well -- should resign for stooping so low). 
  2. In general, the authorities must listen when there are grievances and discontent among the populace. Strong-arming and instilling fear into people is effective only for a while, and if the recent protests show anything, it is that people can only be afraid for so long. Everyone has a breaking point. 

But who am I kidding? If the transition to the previous four points seems a bit jarring, it’s because there was a chunk about how the authorities might be afraid which would make them susceptible to listening to the masses. But after the internet came back and I got a better grasp of what was going on, I know that to be a false analysis. The authorities are angry and they are clamping down as hard as they can. 

Since you have read this far, I’m going to leave some advice. There was a quote floating around the internet -- during the early days when we were still allowed to exercise some modicum of civil rights -- and it went like this: “Every lie we tell incurs a debt to the truth. Sooner or later, that debt is paid.”

A democratic country should have been able to navigate a sticky situation effectively without it turning into total chaos

If such idealisms were true, Bangladesh (not just Bangladesh really, but the world at large) wouldn’t be in the situation it is in currently. But I know this much, that people are at the limit of their patience. People are blistering with rage and discontent. My advice would be to hold on to this rage. My advice would be to hold on to this discontent. Some things will have to be done by people at large (for example, the halls in DU seemingly succeeded in banning BCL. Hopefully, DU follows BUET and bans all kinds of student politics -- especially BCL). 

There have been people -- good people -- who have come out of this mess as leaders, people with the potential to do much more than just abolish the unfair quota systems. One of the reasons that the current authorities have been in power for so long is that there are no viable alternatives. So the people who have come out as leaders -- the people that have the potential to be good alternatives in the future, they need to be given space. 

Furthermore, at least some people who have been in the movements will join the state apparatus in the future. While it may be very improbable they will be able to change things from the inside, they should nevertheless try. After all, they owe it to the people who have been killed. 

Last of all, what I want you to do is remember. Remember the cartoonist called Kishore. Remember an innocent university student named Abu Sayed -- the bravery he showed facing the barrel of a gun. Remember Farhanul Islam Bhuyian, his sweet little face as he smiled into the camera. Remember Tahir Zaman Priyo, a journalist who was shot dead while doing his job (a journalist who has left a child behind … sounds familiar?). Remember Shafkat Samir, whose only crime was trying to close a window because of all the tear shells (a bullet pierced his eyes and flew out of his skull. Ismail Hossain, a member of the ruling Awami League’s Dhaka City unit, advised him to not pursue legal charges -- something he claims to have done on advice from the police -- and bury the body as soon as possible. Can you imagine? A child -- an 11-year-old -- dies and what do the authorities do? Tell the parents to not seek justice).

Remember every life that has been snatched away, everything that is being done and will be done in the future in the name of safety and stability. Remember, because remembering is strength. Remembrance is ammo for the future. 

 

Raihan Ashraf is a freelance contributor.