According to Adam, as a highest troop-contributing country in the world, Bangladesh should get more commanding posts in UN peacekeeping operations in the headquarters and the field level.
The participation of the South Asian countries has been coming down, why?
Adam: The participation of the South Asian countries’ troops as relative share of the total has decreased slightly from the historic level of 51% of all troops in 2006 to now 33%, which has been an average for the last 20 years. So, this has not necessarily gone below very far.
At the same time, their policing contributions have increased. At present South Asia provides 35% of all the UN police force. So, there is mixed trend. The East and West African countries and Southeastern countries have been contributing more troops.
Why has the number of army personnel in the peacekeeping missions been coming down? Is this because of objection from the local people or is it for other reasons?
I think it is less about the local population and how they feel. They do not tend to have the decision making authority when the question is of what troops come from where. I think South Asia had police forces that they were able to contribute. Unlike some other countries, this increases due to the increase in what they call formed police unit … So, I think it is less a question of what host population want…(On reduction of troop) I think 33% of all UN troops coming from the region is about the right percentage. It is low in terms of the (previous) 51%. But I think, 33% is still higher than any other region by far.
Do you think the UN peacekeeping has been facing shortage of funds?
Yes, I do think so. I think budgets have not kept up with actual cost of peace keeping in many countries and many TCCs (troops contributing countries) like Bangladesh have to deal with the consequences.
The implications of these, I think, depressed peace keeping budgets. They should be higher than they are. As a result of the financial crisis over the last few years you have seen an artificial ceiling on troops’ number, also on the budget. I think that negatively impacts peace keeping, and makes it harder for your troops to do the job.
The troops have been risking their lives, but they have been getting the same amount money. Why this reluctance from the western countries to increase the pay?
I think it is the general need to tighten the budget, to tighten the expenditure of peacekeeping. They are actually trying to keep expenditure below a certain level. And as you know, in many countries, it is difficult to explain its population why you are spending too much money on UN peacekeeping.
The US pays a very large percentage of the peacekeeping budget ... sometimes that can be difficult to explain to the American public, even though it is a small percentage of the defence expenditure. Every country who contributes to the budget of peacekeeping has a responsibility to keep cost as low as possible as it is tax payers’ money. So, I understand the pressure.
At the same time, as you pointed out, the troops have been receiving the same amount for about a decade. And I think many people, most people in the UN, agree that the pay should increase. You have seen the pay increase last year. So, there is an agreement of the western countries with the TCCs, according to which there would be regular review of the number of troops and pay rates.
Is there any possibility of reducing the number of Bangladeshi peacekeepers in the changed situation?
I think there is a chance, that can happen. Bangladesh has a lot of good things going for them in terms of troops’ contributions. They are one of the few countries that is willing to go to almost any mission. Many countries would not go to certain missions. Bangladesh is willing to go to any mission.
One of the big things is they do not want to restrict their participation … So, the UN appreciates that … BIPSOT is another feather in your cap in terms of training experience and the great facilities they have. In fact you are one of the big leaders in training peacekeepers. Bangladesh peacekeepers have high level of training.
There are 115 or 116 countries contributing troops and some of them have been trying hard to contribute more troops. Indonesia is one, Mongolia is another; China is increasing their troops. And there is increased competition. So Bangladesh will have to continue to work on further developing their capabilities ... not only on troops, but also on equipment.
I think equipment is a big part of peacekeeping capabilities. They have helicopters, airlifts; they are soon to get C130s from the US which can be a big deal for you. But all the capacities they use in the engineering equipment, the APCs (armed personnel carrier), things like that ... keeping up with the latest would be an important thing to do as well.
Bangladesh has been demanding more commanding posts in the UN peacekeeping mission. Should Bangladesh get more commanding posts?
Yeah. So, it is the contention of the big TCCs. With your large number of troops, you have the right to have a commanding post as well. And the general practice is the more troops you gave, the more commanding posts you should also have. So, I do not disagree with that. And I think if you give more troops, you should have some commanding posts in the fields and the headquarters.
Bangladesh is under-represented in that respect. Bangladesh does have one of the most senior posts in the UN headquarters: the under-secretary general for the department of field support Ms Ameerah Haq. She was the mission chief in the East Timor. She did an excellent job and she represents Bangladesh extremely well at the UN. I believe Bangladesh has a force commander position.
Many countries love to have the posts of under-secretary general and force commander. In that respect I do not think Bangladesh is not that under-represented. They could have few more posts in the headquarters and the field. So, the Bangladesh government and the armed forces should push for more such posts.
There are allegations of immoral activities by the peacekeepers? Does it question the role of the UN peacekeepers in the host country?
No country is immune from the immoral activities such as sexual exploitation. The UN maintains “zero tolerance” for sexual exploitation. That can happen, the troops are in stations for 12 months.
It is very detrimental to the UN presence in the country. It is possibly the worst thing that the UN can have happen … It is a big problem.
How do you rate the role of the Bangladeshi peacekeepers?
As you know they are the top troop-contributing country in the world. So they are really leaders in the UN peacekeeping operations and have been for the past 10 years. They are highly valued because they will go anywhere and will go without restriction. And this is a rare thing among the TCCs and that’s really one of the best things that can be. As a troops-contributing country you should go where you are needed and you are asked. And Bangladesh has been doing that very well.
Is there any chance of the UN peacekeeping getting hampered if the armed forces got involved in country’s governance?
There is a general trend that the UN examines the commitment of the armed forces to the democratic process during the selection process. So, there may be some impact on Bangladesh’s role as peacekeepers, though it varies from country to country.