Why the garments sector needs more taxpayers

At Rana Plaza a nation was honoured by the bravery of volunteers, but why were plain clothes running in to save the workers within? Why were so many rules flouted and inspectors ignored in this, our most precious industry?

Could it be that the lives that were lost, went as a result of our tiny tax base and the institutional lack of capacity that this entails?

The government attempted to legislate its way out; however, much of the tragedy of Rana Plaza is a story of illegality. The building was expanded illegally, the land arguably acquired illegally, the construction built contrary to existing codes. So more laws are almost as good as no laws.

The inspectors for the sector are said to number only 19 with limited transport. This gives us a glimpse into how scarce resources are for regulation of an industry that accounts for 75% of exports and is worth around $19bn.

The shock of Rana Plaza has induced movement amongst foreign multinationals who source in the country, to club together to formulate their own accords on building safety. The only binding one to date would cover only around one-fourth of the garment work force when implemented.

Begging the question, what happens to the remaining approximately 2.7 million workers? The government has legislation but the need for private stakeholders to make such agreements exposes a fundamental abrogation of law due ultimately to this serious lack of capacity, because at the end of the day not enough of us are paying taxes.

We have multiple reasons for not doing so, for instance a lack of trust in the institutions we pay them to. However, if we want trustworthy institutions we all need to pay for them so we all get the services and rights we deserve, when we need them most.

A senior member of the Bangladesh Bank estimates (requesting anonymity) that the country has just over 1 million tax payers of a total population of 160 million. Tax intake as a percentage of GDP is about 9%, putting it near the bottom in the list of nations, near to a handful of countries in Africa and just above the oil rich nations of the Middle East.

The US has a tax intake around 27% of GDP, whilst the OECD nations have an average percentage of around 35% and Norway, with the highest living standards on the planet operating on 43%.

This is largely because of the informality of much of the Bangladesh economy and because “there is a lot of evasion and avoidance,” said Professor Mustafizur Rahman, executive director of the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD), a leading Dhaka think-tank.

Meaning that the GDP figures (and the percentage that tax intake constitutes) are probably conservative. Professor Mustafizur estimates that the “black economy” is equivalent to about 40-60% the size of the formal economy.

This means with the GDP of the country at about $120bn, there is roughly $60bn unaccounted for, being spent by people who inhabit and make money in the country without contributing to the services which we rely on when, for instance, we are trapped underneath eight floors of rubble.

The small tax intake is a major hurdle that the IMF has taken on board and is attempting to fix. The impositions that a small tax intake causes are multiple for the garment sector.

Much was made of the low wages that garment workers receive. The sector has a minimum wage of about $38 (Tk3,000) per month since 2010. Pressure has been applied to the government and factory owners to raise this threshold, with some demanding a doubling.

This has meant that wages have actually been falling if we take into account the 9% average inflation rate that has been prevalent over the last three years.

However, industry heads say this will be hard to feasibly stomach. If they raise the minimum wage, China, who’s minimum wage is around $138 per month, will suddenly become a cheaper place to source garments.

Because of the tiny tax intake the government is forced to impose “[import] tariffs that increase the cost of trade” according to the Heritage Foundation.

These amounted to some 45% for imports of textiles, until the finance minister slashed it to 20% in the most recent budget. Similar tariffs exist for capital goods such as machinery. A lack of machinery and physical capital helps to make Bangladeshi labour unproductive in comparison to rivals.

Import duties are only necessary for key imports and industries because the government lacks the ability to raise taxes elsewhere.

If manufacturers paid a cheaper price on importing a German sewing machine or a metre of fabric, their margins would be bigger, which would then translate into a greater ability to pay living wages. Import duties moreover only account for 0.4% of all government revenue intake according to the CPD.

Infrastructure was listed as a prime cause for concern in “Bangladesh: The next hot spot in apparel sourcing” a survey of industry heads conducted by consultants McKinsey & Co. Infrastructure has rightly been a priority for the current government. Its dire state is acutely felt in the garment sector, massively increasing lead times.

Getting goods to overseas customers or vice versa is a slow, costly affair. Here again the additional expenses placed on business by poor infrastructure lead to smaller margins that equate to cutting corners elsewhere including in safety.

Electricity has been another major area of infrastructural failure for the sector, which is affected by the small tax intake. The floors of Rana Plaza and indeed the surrounding buildings vibrated every time the multiple heavy generators were turned on.

All the generators were placed at the rear of the building and not necessarily on the ground floor.

Those inside the structure said that on the fateful morning of April 24 the building collapsed soon after the generators were turned on. These regular reverberations in the reclaimed swampland could well have been the catalyst for the building’s ultimate collapse.

Cost of mains electricity is about three times cheaper than power from diesel generators. Had the Rana Plaza factories not needed generators it might have still been standing today.

To afford the facility regular electricity the government would have needed more tax money to build all those stalled power plant projects or manage the grid.

Underlining much of the material shortcomings of a tiny tax intake is the dire institutional lack of capacity. This is acutely felt with law and order, which can only be described as a subjective affair at the whims of whichever Begum holds power.

To strengthen institutional capacity above and beyond party politics one needs proper funding so that businesses or workers can access justice regardless of status or party affiliation. There is no incentive to abide by universalised laws or rules if funding is only gained through patronage.

The lack of such legal safeguards is felt across the economy and results in capital flight to the tune of some $3bn annually compared with 2012’s FDI figure of $1.7bn, according to the most recent budget.

If the institutions that safeguard economic activity are not there, we are left with what Shadab Sajid of W&W Commodities traders terms an economic “five year cycle” where political instability trumps institutional guarantees.

This results in low investment and domestic lending with a decline witnessed in the most recent budget. Because, as the IMF puts it “the main risk stems from an intensification of civil strife.” Civil strife is not solved equitably because the institutions for the rule of law lack capacity due to a lack of funding, and so are at the whims of the party in power, as opposed to the law itself.

This induces investors to utilise the country’s cheap labour to make money, before taking their money elsewhere.

Much of this is to be expected in a developing nation. However, there are several reasons why Bangladesh should not simply wait under the impression that low-end manufacturing will develop the country on its own.

The first of these is demographics; Bangladesh is experiencing the most advantageous dependency ratio in its history, a greater proportion of people at working age in relation to their dependents.

Another is the long-term feasibility of export agreements; the EU is the single largest destination for garment exports. Continued weakness and the possibility of further tremors in the garment industry ahead do not bode well.

The EU’s status as the lead destination is shored up by duty free trade access; should this disappear the country’s largest export industry would in a stroke face an uncertain future. The country and sector are in effect subsidised by EU governments – this cannot and should not be relied upon.

Profits need to be harnessed to create new jobs, higher up the food chain and in different sectors. Institutional capacity to allow this, therefore, needs to be built by the only universal arbiter the country has – the government. Without this the hard work that is done by those in factories will not be kept in the country and will not go towards developing it as a whole.

There is virtually no historical precedence of a country developing without strong government affirmative action anywhere in the world. “Virtually all of today’s rich countries used protectionism and subsidies to promote their infant industries,” writes Cambridge University economist, Ha Joon-Chang.

This does not mean that you need an ill-informed Mujib-esque nationalised economy; it means that the government must take an informed and proactive role to promote the dynamism of the private sector, to ensure that the toil of those in our thousands of garment factories will be felt for generations to come.

Elites contend that more taxpayers would mean more resources going into corrupt, unproductive pockets. This may well be true but therein lies a Catch-22; to remove corruption you need capacity, without which a poorly regulated stigmatised industry will be unlikely to develop out of the “dark satanic mills” towards the Asian dream.