Maidul Islam is Assistant Professor in Political Science at the Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta. The book, Limits of Islamism, is a comparative analysis of the ideological articulations of Jamaat-e-Islami in contemporary India and Bangladesh; the prospects, weaknesses, and limits of Jamaat remain the concerns of the book.
What made you embark on this particular project of looking at the limits and limitations of a certain kind of Islamism in South Asia?
The prevalent academic literature on Islamism has a “Greater Middle Eastern” focus that does not represent the globality, heterogeneity, and plurality of the Muslim world.
India and Bangladesh are home to the third and fourth largest concentration of Muslims in the world after Indonesia and Pakistan, constituting around 20% of the world’s total Muslim population.
While researching on contemporary Islamist ideology, one cannot overlook India and Bangladesh with such huge concentration of Muslims -- the prime constituency of Islamism.
Also, there is the dearth of academic literature on Islamism in India and Bangladesh. Whatever research has been done on Islamism in South Asia in general and Jamaat-e-Islami in particular, has been largely Pakistan-centric.
In this context, I try to explore the ideological articulations of Islamism by locating the limits or overlapping boundaries of Islamic religion and a specific ideological articulation in South Asia, inspired by the discursive traditions of Islam.
While examining various claims of Islamism, I also trace the limitations of the Islamists in resisting neo-liberal capitalism in South Asia.
How would you characterise Jamaat-e-Islami in Bangladesh -- politically, socially, economically?
Like many Islamist parties, the Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami wants to establish an “authentic” or puritan Islamic state, governed by the Islamic Sharia.
It argues that the religion of Islam is a political ideology and a guide to programmatic political action.
It constructs a political imaginary while presenting Islam as a totality, which has ideal socio-economic, political, moral and spiritual goals, while giving Islamic justifications for its specific modes of political thinking and action. Jamaat-e-Islami believes in a certain version of internationalism via the idea of Ummah (imagined global community of Muslims believers).
It is fundamentally opposed to nationalism and, in effect, antagonistic to ethno-linguistic nationalism (particularly, Bengali nationalism) that was the ideological basis of Bangladesh. No wonder, it opposed the creation of Bangladesh. Many Jamaatis were aligned with the Pakistan army against the forces of Bangladesh liberation.
How would you put Jamaat-e-Islami in the context of ‘world Islamism,’ given that the US at one point saw Jamaat as something they called ‘moderate Islamist?’
The ideological manifestations of Jamaat-e-Islami are important because the founder of Jamaat, Sayyid Abul A’la Maududi, attempted to ideologise and reinterpret Islamic texts, history, and tradition, which had tremendous influence on a number of 20th-century Islamist movements.
Jamaat-e-Islami is a moderate Islamist organisation in South Asia, which aspires to restructure the prevalent socio-political system in line with Islamist precepts.
It can be also labelled as constituting of parliamentary Islamists, who have adopted parliamentary democratic methods like participation in elections and mass mobilisations, although members of Jamaat, at least during the Bangladesh Liberation War, followed extremist and violent methods while being associated with several counter-insurgency armed groups, notably, the al-Badr, the al-Shams, and the Razakars.
The Jamaat-e-Islami in Bangladesh and elsewhere maintains that it offers something, a formula to Muslim, even human, well-being, that is paradigmatically different from forces and ideologies of modernity. How do you asses this?
An Islamist party like Jamaat argues that “man-made ideologies” and other religions are bound to fail, as they cannot resolve the fundamental problems of humanity (gross inequality and injustice).
Therefore, they project Islam as an emancipatory ideology for all of humanity. However, we need to conceptually differentiate between modernity and modernisation.
Modernity is abstract, philosophical, value-laden, and prescribes a certain way of life or an “attitude,” instead of being a period of history, to quote Michel Foucault.
In contrast, modernisation is concrete, scientific, technological, and infrastructural progress with a developmental paradigm along with a vision of a leap forward from the relatively backward scientific and technological age. Jamaat has accepted modernisation.
However, Jamaat rejects the Western forms of modernity that promote the Western normative ideas of secularism, liberty, equality, justice, nation-state, law, democracy, rights etc.
This being said, a political party like Jamaat is profoundly a modern phenomenon with its own vague ideas of Islamic modernity.
Such an idea of Islamic modernity would have been impossible to construct without borrowing and reinterpretations of Western knowledge systems in an Islamic context.Islamism can be conceptualised as a product of the discontents of Euro-American modernity in Muslim societies.
The second part of this interview will be published tomorrow.