Climate finance and Bangladesh: A reality check

Climate change is no longer a prediction, but a harsh reality. Whether or not we accept it, it is happening all over the world in various forms -- cyclones, drought, flood, landslide etc. Can we reverse it? The instant answer is no. There are smart ways to tackle climate change; be adaptive to it and check the factors of climate change ie reduction of GHGs which falls in the area of mitigation. In both ways, huge investment is involved, which is really difficult, especially for the least developed countries to manage who are normally the innocent victims of climate change.

The impact of climate change would get worse even if a mandatory global arrangement on reducing missions could be reached, as the adverse climate change risks in following decades have already been locked by existing carbon stock. The 21st session of the conference of the parties to the UNFCCC, which is due to be held in December 2015, in Paris, is expected to be able to reach to an agreement to limit temperature rise to 2°C above pre-industrial levels.

Ironically, by climate resilience people tend to mean being adaptive to climate change. In reality, it seems to be a kind of compulsion as there is no other place to go. Aila and Sidr-hit coastal areas have virtually became unliveable; no water, no crops, and long-term damage to the communication network have made the entire locality inaccessible.

Anyway, being the innocent victims of climate change, the most affected least developed countries can legitimately claim compensation from the main contributors of GHGs. Bangladesh is no exception; as per German Watch’s Global Climate Risk Index (CRI), Bangladesh is the most vulnerable nation to climate change. In fact, its entire coastal population is at high risk of rising sea levels. National Geographic predicted that in 2100, 10 to 30 million people along the southern coast would be displaced. The situation would force “Bangladeshis to crowd even closer together or else flee the country as climate refugees.”

Already, the affected areas are experiencing a drastic fall in population, which is not a normal phenomenon; rather, due to an extreme environment in affected areas, local inhabitants were compelled to relocate to other areas. Bangladesh has a good strategic framework aimed at tackling climate change -- National Action Plan on Adaptation (NAPA) of 2005 and the Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan (BCCSAP) of 2009. Setting up the Bangladesh Climate Change Trust Fund (BCCTF) by own budget allocation of $100m was an example of our determination to combat climate change. 

Bangladesh Climate Change Resilience Fund (BCCRF) is a multi-donor trust fund for climate change which channeled over $188m in grant funds. BCCSAP has identified six pillars namely: 1) Food security, social protection and health, 2) comprehensive disaster management, 3) infrastructure, 4) research and knowledge management, 5) mitigation and low carbon development, 6) capacity building and institutional strengthening; under the six pillars there are 40 plus actions. Both BCCTF and BCCRF support the actions of the six pillars. But the country cannot go far depending on its own resources in addressing the adaptation and mitigation when cost involved in both processes is huge. Therefore, harnessing available sources of international climate finance is a must.

Conventionally, climate and development finance were channeled to LDCs mainly through multi-lateral agencies via indirect access modality, which often compromise country ownership. From the Adaptation Fund to more recently, the GCF, LDCs are able to access funding directly if they are accredited following the criteria of the fund management. Accessing international climate finance is a huge challenging task; enhanced institutional capacity is a pre-condition to overcome the access barriers as most of these funds follow high standard fiduciary systems and environmental and social safeguards. Good management practice, transparency, and track records -- all are essential to gain direct access to the international climate finance.

Due to the UN processes on climate change and COP, the international community appears to be responsive to address the resource needs of most affected countries, especially the LDCs. But the complicated architecture of international climate finance appears to be a kind of barrier for the LDCs in terms of accessibility. Fund delivery modalities induce competitive environment for the developing countries and their delivery partners (eg development agencies) in managing their shares in international climate finance. Countries like China, India, Brazil, Indonesia, and South Africa are keen on mitigation actions depriving the adaptation activities which are priorities of the LDCs.

Allocations for LDCs in Adaptation Fund and GCF justify the needs of the LDCs, but the fiduciary standard and ESMS (environment and social management system) may keep many of the LDCs away from having access to the allocated fund. Good news is, many multi-lateral development partners, even the GCF, run global readiness programmed for the LDCs to enable them to access the international climate finance.

For example, GIZ, UNDP, and GCF offer readiness supports which mainly focus on institutional capacity of the focal point and NDA (national designated authority), identifying the potential NIEs (national implementing entities), their capacity building and developing strategic framework or project pipeline. It depends on the country capacity to make the best use of readiness support and get them ready for direct access to the fund.

Mainstream multi-lateral international climate fund:

The main international sources of climate finance are: Environment Facility (GEF), Adaption Fund, Least Developed Countries Fund (LDCF), Adaptation for Smallholder Agriculture Program (ASAP), Global Climate Change Alliance (GCCA), Climate Investment Funds, UN-REDD Readiness Program, and recently established Green Climate Fund (GCF) which is being managed under global arrangement in a more transparent and inclusive way; board of directors are drawn from member countries. A brief account on what Bangladesh has gained from international climate funds may be useful to review our place in the arena of climate finance.

GEF 3 was established in 1991, to support activities related to bio-diversity, land degradation, chemicals and waste, international water, sustainable management of forests, and climate change (both adaptation and mitigation) in the context of development projects and programs. GEF STAR allocation is country-specific, and targeted towards mitigation activities.

On the other hand, GEF Least Developed Countries Fund (LDCF) and Special Climate Change Fund (SCCF) are two special funds to support the adaptation activities. Bangladesh, under its current LDCF ceiling of $30m, has already accessed $23.5m. Another project of $6.5m is under process at the GEF. For mitigation activities, Bangladesh has accessed $20.54m through national projects. Also, Bangladesh receives funds for climate change under global and regional projects of the international development agencies. Sometimes country-specific allocation under regional and global projects is difficult to find out. However, UNDP, UNEP, WB, ADB, and FAO are the international development/financial agencies through whichever channeled funding in Bangladesh.

The adaptation fund was established in 2001, to finance adaptation projects and programs in developing countries that are vulnerable to the adverse effects of climate change. As its website states, AF is financed by a 2% levy on CERs (certified emission reduction) by CDM (clean development mechanism) and also with funds from other sources. AF has same provisions of direct and indirect access (ie multi-lateral implementing entities and regional implementing entities).

Usually, the secretary of the Ministry of Environment and Forest is the “Designated Authority” (DA) of Bangladesh to AF. The same modality is being followed by the parties in seeking resources from AF. Project and program must be submitted directly through accredited national, regional, and multilateral implementing entities. Among the SAARC countries, the National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) of India is accredited by the AF. Other SAARC countries have access to AF through the MIE. India, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives received fund from AF for project implementation. Bangladesh could not access to the resources of AF; no Bangladeshi national agency is accredited by the AF. 

Adaptation for Smallholder Agriculture Program (ASAP) was launched by International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) in 2012 to channel climate finance to smallholder farmers for building their resilience to climate change. Bolstering defences against rising seas and saline-tolerant farming are the climate change activities in IFAD loans and grants in Bangladesh.

Bangladesh is a recipient country of Global Climate Change Alliance, an initiative of the European Union to build alliance on climate change between EU and the most affected poor developing countries having least capacity to deal with climate change.  

Bangladesh Climate Change Resilience Fund (BCCRF) was established in 2010 to act as a co-ordinated financing mechanism by the GoB and development partners to support the Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan. $188.2m grant funds were channeled by seven bilateral and multi-lateral development partners to finance six studies and six investment projects, mostly of CC adaptation. However, the project implemented by IDCOL titled “Solar Irrigation Program -- a green energy initiative” of $24.5m can be considered as a CC mitigation project. BCCRF is envisioned, inter alia, to bring global climate change funding to Bangladesh.

Climate Investment Funds (CIF) was established in 2008; it consists of two distinct funds -- the Clean Technology Fund (CTF) and the Strategic Climate Fund (SCF), have an $8.1bn pledged fund. The following four key programs are included in CIFs to help 63 developing countries pilot low-emissions and climate-resilient development: 1.Clean Technology Fund (CTF), 2. Forest Investment Program (FIP), 3. Pilot Program Climate Resilience (PPCR), 4. Scaling Up Renewable Energy Program (SREP).

SCF includes the last three sub-funds to finance piloting of new development approaches or scale up activities focusing a specific climate change challenge or sectoral response. Bangladesh was one of the three countries for which the PPCR was approved. Bangladesh has received $110m ($50m grant and $60m near-zero interest concessional loan) under PPCR program. CIF projects are executed by the multi-lateral development banks/institution. The WB, IFC, and ADB are the executing agencies of CIF projects in Bangladesh.

UN-REDD (Reduction of Desertification and Deforestation) readiness program is also a funding source for CC mitigation through forestry and land use change. Bangladesh has accessed $2.3m from UN-REDD. Bangladesh is highly likely to receive $30m (grant) from FIP window of CIF.

GCF was established in 2010 with huge expectations of raising funds to address the estimated climate finance needs in mitigation (around $350bn per year until 2029) and adaptation (projected at $70-100bn per year by 2050). As formally committed by the heads of developed countries, yearly $100bn will be mobilised for GCF by 2020. Claiming to be the central global investment vehicle for climate change finance, GCF is intended to operate at a larger scale to promote low-emission, climate-resilient growth. It allocates equal share of resources for mitigation and adaptation with special attention to the most vulnerable countries. Moreover, for LDCs it has kept a special allocation of $10bn for adaptation. GCF seems to be more flexible, catalysing both public and private, accommodating country systems and responsive to the needs of the countries. For example, “fit for purpose” accreditation model/approach is different from the Adaptation Fund.

Climate Funds Update has the key details of the multi-lateral and bilateral climate funding. Multilateral funds are mainly administered by the boards (eg Adaptation Fund, GCF etc), international financial institutions like the World Bank, African Development Bank, and UN agencies like IFAD and UNDP. Bilateral funds are being managed by the development agencies of respective countries.

In terms of focus area, delivery modality, delivery partner, funding criteria, fund ceiling -- the architecture of international climate fund is complex, and offers very limited access for the least developing nations to their governance system. LDCs should focus more on direct access to international climate fund through bargaining for decision making role in the fund management as well as developing their own institutional capacity to overcome the barriers of direct access.

National capacity and international climate finance: For access to the available international climate finance, very high standard fiduciary and ESMS (Environmental and Social Management System) are required to be in place. Bangladesh over the years has developed strategic framework aimed at tackling the climate change. Financing the implementation of action plans under strategic framework is not totally under our control. For example, the projected estimate of $5bn for the full implementation of BCCSAP, or the recurrent expenditure as estimated by the World Bank to protect our communication network against the adverse impacts of climate change is so high that the national economy cannot bear the load. The UNDP study shows 80% of climate-related programs in Bangladesh are funded domestically, and 20% by external sources.

Therefore, resource mobilisation from the external sources has become imperative for us. And here lies the importance of direct access to international climate fund. Even from the point of climate justice, it is our due share to claim. Bangladesh must strive to gain direct access to the international climate fund including the GCF. There is no shortcut to gain access to the international climate finance. Standard fiduciary system, ESMS, efficient and transparent project management system, good procurement act, better reporting system and most importantly, a good track record in practising these regulatory frameworks are essential at the institutional level. Along with these institutional arrangements, a pool of skilled staff is needed to run the system. Therefore, the institutional capacity of the national agencies that are legally mandated to undertake projects/programs necessitate a full review on urgent basis. Based on the review, well-targeted interventions can be undertaken to revamp the institutional set up aligning with the requirements of international climate finance mechanism. Our dependence on the MIEs will not go unless our national agencies achieve direct access for which accreditation is a requirement.