Unearthing Buddha

An exhibition of Buddhist Art, “Buddhist Art of Myanmar,” has recently opened in New York.

In his review of the exhibition, Guardian correspondent, Jason Farago, quotes from the fascinating work by George Orwell, the famous British writer and author of the immortal 1984, his first novel, Burmese Days, “Beauty is meaningless until it is shared.”

Farago goes on to write of the flowering of Buddhism in Myanmar, “since the establishment of Buddhism by ‘Indian’ monks around 500AD.”

In fact, according to a number of Buddhist authorities, the Buddha himself made his way to Pegu, in today’s Myanmar, which would date the arrival of Buddhism in Myanmar to some time around sixth century BCE; and since it is also believed that Ashoka, the third of the Mauryan emperors, pushed the frontiers of his Empire at least as far south as the Naf river, today’s border between Bangladesh and Myanmar, in the fourth century BCE, there seems little doubt that the Buddhist tradition in Myanmar dates to at least eight centuries earlier.

There is also very little doubt that the “Indian” monks to which he refers would, today, many of them, be referred to as Bangladeshi monks.

Ramkot Temple complex on the outskirts of Ramu, in Cox’s Bazar district of Bangladesh, asserts a foundation by Ashoka in the third century BCE. And it is worth recalling that, for much of its history, Ramu was, in fact, located in the Kingdom of Arakan, the greater part now in today’s Myanmar.

For Bangladesh, for whom a burgeoning inbound tourism business, such as that which Myanmar is currently experiencing, supported by such as the New York exhibition, could, by World Tourism Organisation figures of international value and employment statistics, create up to four million new jobs, and generate up to $10bn income annually, there is every reason to feel neglected. But, clearly, if there is neglect, it is founded in Bangladesh itself.

Buddhist traditions in the lands around the Ganges delta, which is now at the heart of Bangladesh, as well as the significant part of ancient, “north east India,” especially the Ganges basin, much of which is also now in the lands of Bangladesh, are certainly more ancient than those of Myanmar, and just as rich; indeed, historically, far richer.

Whether the Buddhist tradition in Myanmar commenced with the arrival of monks from north of the Naf river as late as the sixth century AD/CE, or far earlier, there can be little doubt that they arrived, by land from today’s Bangladesh, and, if by water, from around the Ganges and its delta, and they brought with them centuries of expertise.

In fact, we have clear evidence of the development of art forms in the lands around the Ganges about 4,000 years ago. The “vanishing wax” system of metal casting continues to be practised at Dhamrai, close to Dhaka, producing, in brass, astonishingly lovely works of art.

There seems, in fact, little doubt that the bronze and brass images of Buddhist tradition that is abound in Myanmar, as elsewhere in south east Asia, including Thailand and Cambodia, have their origins in skills developed in that early industrialised civilisation around these lands of the Ganges.

But it is in the museums of Bangladesh, as well as in the monuments, the temples, vihara and early Islamic constructs, which are abound in these lands of Bangladesh, that architectural, sculptural and monumental works of art can be so readily admired.

There is little doubt that the creation of what we might reasonably refer to as art significantly predates even Buddhism.

Evolving, like the early Sanskrit language, and the art of such written form as the famous stories of the Mahabharata, at least a millennium before the Common Era, and artefacts, such as those excavated from the mid to last millennium BCE site at Wari Bateshwar, near Narsingdi, bear testimony to the social environment that had sufficiently evolved to regard both religious images, and personal decoration, as accessible.

There is also little doubt that, even more so than the Hindu, and later, Jain period, it was the Buddhists who certainly began the flowering of a tradition of sculpture in both stone and cast metal that almost certainly lies at the foundation of much East Asian art for the next thousand years; and, arguably, right up to modern times.

It is said that it was the Mauryan period, the first ruler of which converted to Jainism, and the third, famously, to Buddhism, that saw the evolution of such art forms as architecture and sculpture, especially, from wood and clay, to the more enduring materials that have, for the most part, lasted until today.

Certainly, no one visiting the site museums, and such collections as those as Varendra in Rajshahi, or the National Museum in Dhaka, can doubt that the skills of both builders and artists of the late centuries before the Common Era, and the first millennium of the Common Era, working in the Indian subcontinent, in any way compare unfavourably to those working in ancient Persia, ancient Greece and Rome, amongst many other sites of artistic flowering.

The astonishing intricacy of carved basalt, and other hard stone of volcanic origin, of, largely, religious imagery, from Hindu, through Jain, Buddhist and even Islamic periods, compare, in their very evident skills, with those from any other part of the world.

Such works have, of course, been extensively looted, and continue to be so, whole troves of Hindu brasses reappearing on the markets of USA having been, “removed for renovation,” from South Asian, and, no doubt, East Asian sites and museums, too.

It seems a pity that the work of such skilled artists, many of whom certainly originated from, and worked in, the lands of Bangladesh, are not receiving the international recognition they deserve.

The policy of the Archaeology Department in Bangladesh, to forbid photography of collections under their care, ostensibly to protect the materials, both inhibits a wider audience for the tremendous ancient talents, from which many others, including those from Myanmar being celebrated in New York, undoubtedly developed, and, of course, facilitates illegal trade.

To see, advertised online, from California, Hindu works of art, with a certified origin of Bangladesh, at prices from $65,000, speaks volumes for the illegal trade in such works of art, which are more likely to adorn private mansions than the galleries where they could awaken a popular appreciation of the great traditions of the lands of Bangladesh.

But it is perhaps the architectural detail of Buddhist Vihara frequently to be found, recycled, in such masterpieces as Kasumba Mosque, and cladding the Golden Mosque, which can most readily compare with contemporary works anywhere in the world.

And the sculptural masterpieces, perhaps with less secular focus than some of that in the Mediterranean world, also compare in their intricate detail, with any contemporary work from Greece and Rome.

The remnants of that tradition may only linger in places like Dhamrai, and possibly the woodcarving expertise to be found in so many furniture shops around the country.

However, it might be with pride that Bangladeshis could admire the craftsmanship and art of their unidentified ancestors, and potentially share them with the more developed world from which originates tidal waves of tourists, of usually high value, who continue to travel the world seeking evidence of the talents of our forefathers.

The cream of it all is, undoubtedly, the work of Buddhist tradition, much predating, even, the famous four centuries of the famous Pala dynasty. Unquestionably, a tradition of art, and sculpture, especially, to be proud of.

Incredible beauty that, if we could only bring ourselves to share, would certainly acquire greater meaning here in the lands in which so much of it was created, and which gave birth to skills and traditions shared across the world, but could also do so much for both the social and economic prospects of Bangladesh today.