No reason to deny bail to Rubel

A leading member of Bangladesh’s cricket squad for the forthcoming World Cup, Rubel Hossain, has been denied bail in a court case filed under the Women and Children Repression Act.

The case brought by Naznin Akter Happy, a film actress, alleges Rubel had promised to marry her only to backtrack after their personal relationship soured.

For all the attention and gossip generated by this affair, it is self evidently a legally contentious and tendentious matter, as reports suggest it is merely about a relationship between two consenting adults, which went wrong.

Given that Rubel voluntarily presented himself before the court, it is unfair to deny him bail in such a matter. There is no convincing argument to keep him in jail pending trial as his high profile job means he is not likely to abscond.

The argument for denying him bail rests on the seriousness of the charge as Section 9(1) of The Prevention of Oppression Against Women and Children Act 2000, states whoever has sexual intercourse without lawful marriage with a woman by fraud, shall be said to commit rape.

It is wrong in principle for the law to bring affairs between consenting adults into the definition of rape. The absence of coercion also makes it impractical for the law to fairly arbitrate on promises made in private.

At the very least, this act needs to be interpreted narrowly, but would be better amended, as its contentiousness may bring the law into disrepute, and it trivialises the very serious offense of rape.

In the meantime, on the face of the facts available, there is no reason to deny bail to Rubel Hossain. Nor are there any grounds for dropping him from the World Cup squad, in our opinion.