The prime minister is perfectly entitled to remove Posts and Telecommunications Minister Abdul Latif Siddique from the cabinet, following the controversy generated by his comments on Hajj to an audience in New York.
While his remarks were not statements of government policy, and are clearly his own personal opinion, it may nonetheless be fair to describe their content and timing as impolitic. He serves at the PM’s pleasure, and if his statements have embarrassed the government, that is grounds for removal. Similarly, disciplinary action at the party level is a matter for the AL.
However, his remarks should not be used as a cause for demonstrations aimed clearly to gain supposed political advantage.
The bringing of a case under the penal code for hurting religious sentiments strikes us as excessive. Section 295A is intended for far more egregious acts and statements that deliberately and maliciously hurt religious sentiment. Surely it is only vile insult and abuse that are contemplated by the law. To criminalise Latif’s careless remarks would set the bar for legal action dangerously low, in our opinion.
We deplore the fact that a person in a position of such responsibility has shown so little regard for the sentiments of the multitude. However, we do not believe that prosecution is the answer. Losing a cabinet position and public esteem at the end of one’s public life is an apt punishment that fits the transgression.
Furthermore, attempts by certain groups to blatantly use this occasion for political advantage are unacceptable. No public benefit is gained by creating a political bandwagon of outrage on matters of religion, or demanding that he be removed as an MP from parliament, or worse. We believe that as much as most people found the minister’s comments objectionable, they will also see through any coterie trying to exploit it for their own political benefit.