Satellite costs do not add up

The government should rethink its decision to push ahead with BTRC’s project to launch the country’s first satellite.

As the facts stand, there is no clear financial case for this project.

The National Economic Council has approved spending over $380m (Tk2,967 crore) on the Bangabandhu 1 satellite project, against a guaranteed usage of only around $11m a year, which is what Bangladesh spends on satellite rental right now.

Even if it is assumed that most of this usage would be profit, it would take around 40 years, which is more than twice this satellite’s projected lifetime, for the project to earn back its costs.

One mooted reason for going ahead now is the suggestion that Bangladesh could earn an additional $39 million annually by renting out spare capacity to neighbouring countries. This is a highly risky assumption. Satellite costs are becoming ever more competitive and it is probable that Indian and Chinese satellites will be able to provide cheaper alternatives to Bangladesh.

It would be far less risky to simply wait a few more years for Bangladesh’s satellite usage to increase to the point where most of the project’s capacity could be utilised within the country.

In the meantime, taxpayer money could be better spent on improving health and education and investing in the skills needed for Bangladesh to nurture more high technology industries.

That way, when the time comes when the project is financially viable, we will have the capacity to harness more of the finance, resources, and skills needed to develop this project ourselves.