Do not compromise judicial independence

The Law Commission’s proposal that the government reintroduce a previously scrapped article in the constitution that would give parliament the authority to impeach Supreme Court judges is a deeply concerning one given the political realities of this country. We think this is a rather unnecessary move that is likely to compromise judicial independence.

While Suranjit Sengupta’s proclamation that restoring Article 96 of the 1972 constitution is essential for the sovereignty of the parliament may have carried the best intentions, it is sure to raise questions about the government’s motives for supporting such a move. It is not surprising, then, that this proposal has created some controversy and has already been challenged in court.

Jeopardising the judiciary’s autonomy for the sovereignty of the parliament is a poor trade-off and could produce unpleasant consequences. If implemented, the provision may well serve as a tool to manipulate or put pressure on judicial proceedings.

Often, parliament members themselves are a party in these proceedings. Judges who are tasked with delivering a judgment in such cases should be free to do so without the fear of impeachment hanging over their heads. If the government is contemplating the power to impeach judges, perhaps it should also consider giving the public the authority to impeach members of parliament.

Furthermore, due to Article 70 of the constitution, giving parliament the power to impeach Supreme Court judges is tantamount to giving the prime minister that power. If the parliament is allowed to impeach judges, individual members of the parliament should also have the independence to vote against their party.

We urge the government to abandon the Law Commission’s proposal and to protect the foundation of an independent judicial system, where the rule of law is not inhibited by concerns of political repercussions.