Privatisation is the best option for state owned banks

It is common knowledge that Bangladesh’s state-owned commercial banks have not been well managed.

The Ministry of Finance has often been forced to recapitalise them and, in December, the Bangladesh Bank had to work with the IMF to arrange finance to make up capital shortfalls.

It is no coincidence that a state-owned bank was subject to the country’s largest banking fraud. The Banking Division of the Ministry of Finance which had oversight of the state-owned Sonali Bank failed to stop it sanctioning huge loans to Hallmark without any regard for prudent limits on exposure to single borrowers.

Although the finance minister is rightly talking of the need to improve state banks, this is insufficient to overcome their institutional weaknesses.

Private banks have a better track record than state banks because they are less prone to politically influenced appointments and are better managed. They are also doing well in addressing national policy goals, such as tackling financial exclusion, by developing mobile banking services.

Being accountable to private investors, their management is less prone to take unwarranted risks and to act more promptly to rectify weaknesses.

The government should free the regulators to focus on their core roles of protecting depositors’ assets and preventing fraud, rather than continuing to spend taxpayer money to bail out poorly run state banks.

It should reconsider its policy options. In most, if not all cases, the public will be better served if state-owned banks are either privatised or wound down and their assets distributed.