The indictments issued against the director and secretary of Odhikar for publishing a “false report” illustrate the draconian nature of the ICT law, enacted first by BNP in 2006 and amended by AL in 2013.
Odhikar staff have been charged in relation to their report that 61 people died when law enforcers forcibly cleared Hefazat-e-Islam activists out from Motijheel in the early hours of May 6 last year.
The police, who vigorously dispute the figure, have brought charges on the basis that a “false report” has tarnished the image of the state and law enforcement agencies.
If found guilty, the accused face up to fourteen years in jail under the ICT act and seven years under the Penal Code.
Under these laws, any newspaper or other media which publishes reports that can potentially be described as false runs the risk of facing similar charges. The chilling effect on free debate and free media of such laws is self-evident.
Free media not punitive tribunals should be the forum for debate about disputed reports.
Like everyone else, the police and government should debate the facts and veracity of disputed reports within free media. They should not seek to punish citizens for merely disseminating information or points of view with which they disagree.
Even if it is proved that reports are factually incorrect, a potential prison sentence is not the appropriate penalty. Independent observers both inside the country and out have commented on the threat to freedom of expression posed by provisions of the ICT Act. This week’s indictment justifies these fears.
Coming at the same time when so many opposition figures continue to be taken into custody, this latest indictment raises a broader concern of the machinery of the state being misused to clamp down on voices of dissent.