Understanding the importance of judicial independence

The warnings voiced at a recent seminar in Dhaka on judicial independence are undoubtedly worth heeding.

The event, organized by Dhaka Tribune with support from the Royal Norwegian Embassy, brought together prominent speakers and highlighted the real issue of Bangladesh’s judiciary continuing to struggle for genuine independence -- in both structure and practice.

An independent judiciary is not a simple luxury for functioning democracies. It is, in fact, the foundation upon which public trust in the rule of law rests.

When courts are perceived as vulnerable to political pressure, administrative interference, or obscure appointment processes, the people's confidence in justice erodes rapidly, and citizens begin to question whether verdicts are determined by law or by influence.

The recent repeal and lapse of judicial reform ordinances, as highlighted by several speakers, raise troubling concerns: Judicial reform cannot be pursued in sporadic moments of political enthusiasm, only to be rolled back when inconvenient. Constant reversals create uncertainty and weaken already fragile public confidence.

At the same time, independence cannot simply mean barriers to oversight. A judiciary must also remain transparent, accountable, and accessible.

Delayed case disposal, lack of digital transparency, procedural inefficiency, and financial dependence on the executive continue to undermine the effectiveness of courts in Bangladesh. Judicial independence without institutional competence serves little practical purpose for ordinary citizens seeking justice.

Perhaps the most important point raised during the seminar was that true independence is also psychological: Laws and ordinances alone cannot guarantee impartiality if judges themselves do not feel empowered to act without fear or favour.

That culture must be cultivated through merit-based appointments, secure tenure, ethical accountability, and a broader political consensus that courts should never become instruments of partisan interests.

Bangladesh has made progress in this space before, and allowing that progress to be undone would be a national error that we simply cannot afford to make.