Begging the question

We would like to extend qualified support for the government’s move to prohibit begging in some areas of the capital. There is some evidence to suggest that cracking down on this kind of pretty harassment and minor misdemeanour sends a message and sets a tone, thus helping to reduce incidences of more major disturbances, and creating a safer and more livable atmosphere.

People have a right to go about their business without being harassed or intimidated, and there is no question that moving towards a begging-free environment is something that any modern, progressive city should aspire to.

Nor should we see this as an anti-poor move. The vast majority of beggars in the city are only allowed to ply their trade by mafia syndicates who cream off the lion’s share of their take and ruthlessly enforce their territorial claims, dealing harshly with freelancers and those who try to challenge their control.

But in order to underscore that it is not simply turning its back on those who beg for a living, the government must at the same time crack down hard on the gangs or syndicates who control the trade. Begging is one thing. Exploiting and living off the misery of those who have no better option is quite another, and the elimination of the begging industry is long overdue.

At the same time, the government needs to take steps to reach those who are so destitute that begging is their only option. To make an anti-begging initiative credible and not seem like a callous anti-poor policy, the government must step up its services specifically targeted at those who will be hit by the anti-begging initiative.