No case for Rampal

The Rampal coal-based power plant has not received support from any aware sector of our population. The government should pay heed to the people’s demands. Already under intense flak, this project may be detrimental to the government’s popularity and rapidly depreciating political capital.

The major point against this project is that, in this joint venture, Bangladesh will be sharing all the rewards with India equally while incurring the total environmental cost on its own.

The Environmental Impact Assessment already includes most of the concerns raised, and the estimated cost of environment management only is more than Tk10bn. Considering the need to build a separate anchor point to harbour ships importing coal, this project is costly in terms of capital, operational and production expenses. The cost of one unit of power produced in this plant has been independently estimated at more than Tk8: not a viable cost for Bangladesh.

The government is well aware of the environmental hazards from Rampal. The project, in its drafted plan, intends to mitigate all environmental hazards it poses. Historically, such promises have rarely been kept. If this project comes to fruition, our economy will have no choice but to operate the facility even if the promises regarding the environment are not kept.

Due for completion in 2017, this project has little to do in addressing our power shortage immediately. Our nation has little to gain from Rampal and much to lose, and the people are aware of this.

Under the circumstance, it seems that the only reason this government is pressing forward with this plan is to maintain good terms with New Delhi. The damage this will do the government’s already shaky standing among the general public seems a high price to pay for this, let alone the long-term costs to the nation.