No one comes out looking good from the current fracas surrounding the Bangladesh Civil Service exams. Those who aspire to a career in public administration would do well to show respect for the law they some day wish to uphold and to act within it at all times. Their violent protests are an unacceptable way of trying to press their point.
That said, the fact that it was only in response to these protests that the Public Service Commission agreed to cancel the last set of exam results and address the issue of quotas, is equally shameful. What message does this send about how to get one's grievances heard?
Finally, the fact that student cadres of the ruling party saw fit to enter into the fray, clashing violently with protesters, once again demonstrated the way in which the ruling party uses its student front as shock-troops, unleashing them on those it considers enemies of the state.
But to get to the matter at hand, the fundamental problem here lies with the quota system that is used in the selection process for BCS cadres, leading to meritorious candidates being overlooked and unqualified candidates being accepted. It is preposterous that fully 55% of the selected candidates come under the quota. This is a recipe for ensuring bureaucratic inefficiency, the evidence of which is all around us.
It also creates the culture from day one that tells the civil service that who you are is more important than how you perform. The fact that qualification for quota consideration is riddles with corruption need hardly be mentioned.
We need a civil service staffed with the best and the brightest. The Public Service Commission had recommended the abolition of the quota system in 2012. The government has however gone in the opposite direction. It is time to put this right. The quota system needs to be rethought.