Tell the truth

The DMP commissioner’s claim that there were “zero casualties” in the law enforcement drive to clear Motijheel of Hefazat supporters in the early hours of May 6 is simply untrue.

The Dhaka Tribune reporter on the ground was an eyewitness to at least four deaths, and there have been credible reports of as many as 18 more, although the actual figure remains shrouded in doubt, due, in large part to the government’s media blackout of the event. Now the government has compounded that wrong with another grievous one.

What is incontrovertible was that, contrary to the claims made by the DMP, the law enforcement authorities did use live ammunition and Hefazat supporters were killed. To suggest otherwise is an insult to those who died, all lives being sacred, and an insult to the nation, who know full well that what the commissioner said is untrue.

The commissioner could have contented himself with telling the truth: that the outlandish figures being spread by motivated parties is a falsehood, that there was no massacre. He could have argued that law enforcement did its best to minimise casualties, but that, regrettably and tragically, casualties were unavoidable.

He could have acknowledged the pain of those who were killed and their near and dear, and acknowledged that all killing by the state of civilians is the last thing anyone wants. He could have shown remorse and regret for the loss of life, which any sentient human being, and especially a public servant, should feel in such circumstances.

He could have defended the police action as appropriate and made the argument that such force as was used was necessary, and that had less force been used, resistance would have been greater, and casualties might have been higher.

People will disagree as to what level of force was warranted and whether excessive force was used. This is a debate that the rule of law and respect for the dead demands. Sadly, due to the media blackout, we may never know the truth.

But to simply pretend that the killings did not happen and to thus dismiss the concerns that have been raised and, by extension, the lives lost, is unacceptable.