Wrong time to pull the plug

The government’s closing down transmission of Diganta Television and Islamic TV, alongside the raid on the Hefazat-e-Islam protesters camped out at Shapla Chattar in the early hours of May 6, raises questions about its respect for press freedom and simply does not pass the smell test.

The job of the press is to gather the facts and present them to the public, and that is what these channels were doing when they were taken off the air. The government’s position that the channels were shut down for “broadcasting fabricated news and violating the license conditions” strains credulity.

It is perfectly apparent that the real transgression committed by the channels, as far as the government was concerned, was the fact that they had been unflinching in their coverage of the May 5 riots during the day, and the government did not wish to contend with them during and after the crackdown to clear Shapla Chattar in the pre-dawn hours of May 6.

Indeed, as is always the case when it comes to limitations placed on the press by the government, the move was counter-productive, and leaves the government open to the charge that the reason it took these channels off the air is that it had something to hide. It would have been wiser to let them remain on air.

It is one thing to order a media blackout in the interests of maintaining public security so that passions are not inflamed by sensationalistic images whose real time transmission could trigger a breakdown in law and order. It is quite another to shut down the transmission of two TV channels whose broadcast have been a thorn in the government’s side.

To do so during and after a controversial armed crackdown that was bound to lead to accusations of brutality and atrocity was a poor decision that has harmed the government more than anything that the two channels could have possibly broadcast would have.