If ever there was an appropriate case for judicial leniency or presidential clemency it is in the tragic case of Oishee, recently convicted of murdering her parents and sentenced to death as a result.
We are not questioning the verdict nor the honourable judge’s decision to impose the sentence that he did. He followed the law and his conscience, and there can be no questions raised about the probity of the process or the soundness of the judgment rendered.
However, we feel that Oishee’s tender age at the time the murders were committed together with her diminished capacity due to years of drug abuse make her an appropriate candidate for mercy.
Whatever else she may be, she is not a hardened criminal with a long record of heartless crime behind her. She was a misguided girl, caught in a cycle of drug dependency and all its attendant ills, who made a catastrophic and unforgiveable moral choice.
She has been found guilty of a terrible crime, and she must face punishment for it. However, we feel that for one of her years and record, a lesser punishment than the one served would not be inappropriate.
She may have committed a heinous crime, but she is not a lost cause. With appropriate custodial punishment and rehabilitation, she has the potential to make something of her life and atone for her actions, a possibility the death penalty would foreclose.
It should be noted that caught in a downward spiral of drug abuse and degradation from a vulnerable age, she never received the treatment, guidance, or support that could have led to a happier path. For all these reasons, we feel that society should not give up on her just yet.
Even if she was not a child under the law, she was, without question, at a very young and impressionable age, and to be sentenced to death for a single act committed in her teenage years, that we are sure she will spend her whole life regretting, is a severe punishment indeed.
None of this exonerates Oishee for her actions. However, if she were to receive leniency on appeal or, failing that, the president sought to exercise his august powers of clemency in her favour, we think justice would be well served.