Comprehensive reforms needed to reduce backlog of court cases

In its recent report to parliament, the Law Commission called for urgent measures to reduce the burden faced by the millions of citizens who are affected by delays in the hearing and settlement of court cases.

The chronic backlog in the court system is made worse by the nation’s low number of actively working judges.

Since the BJSC was reconstituted in 2007, around 930 new assistant judges and judicial magistrates have been appointed. On past trends, the rate of appointment is too slow to prevent vacancies rising, given the expected number of impending retirements among serving judiciary.

At present, the Appellate Division has seven judges, the High Court around 100, and there are slightly over 1,100 judges actively serving in lower courts.

It is most concerning that around a quarter of the 1,600 budgeted posts for lower court judges are currently vacant. Pressures are obviously most acutely felt in the lower courts, which deal with the vast majority of cases. There are slightly over 15,000 cases pending with the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, and 370,000 with the High Court.  

Clearly, the government needs to act on promises to expedite the appointment of new judges. However, it also needs to address bottlenecks which slow the pace of cases, and look at ways to reduce the number of cases that need to be heard in the first place.

Encouraging alternative dispute resolution mechanisms can help alleviate pressure on the court system and allow speedier and less expensive justice for litigants. Similarly, simplifying court procedures to increase speed and transparency can be used to mitigate delays and create more opportunities to settle cases before trial. 

As around 60% of outstanding civil litigation cases relate to land disputes, it is also clear that reforming the administration of land management could drastically help to lessen burdens on the court system. 

While such measures will require more commitment and funds from the government, they will pay for themselves by making the administration of justice more efficient and effective. This is imperative to help all citizens and reduce scope for corruption in the legal system. We cannot afford to permit citizens and businesses to keep suffering from delays in justice.