The problem with statistics is that the story we tell to explain them is what really matters. For we humans work with stories -- we are (to borrow a phrase from British writer, Terry Pratchett) Pan Narrans, not Homo Sapiens. Sure, numbers are useful, numbers can be accurate, numbers can even reveal the truth, but it's the story that sticks in the human head that goes on to change society and the world.
Which is, for dedicated number crunchers like ourselves, somewhat depressing. But it's still something worth keeping in mind as we consider women in commercial kitchens. Michella Chowdhury took us through some of the apparent unfairness in this newspaper. It's entirely true, as she says, that women do the vast majority of the world's cooking, a less than equal share of the high-end commercial cooking and a tiny and seemingly unfair fraction of the head chef-ing at expensive places.
This is certainly an unequal distribution.
The bigger question though: Is this an unfair one? Having worked in commercial kitchens myself (for more than just a holiday job and from eggs-over-easy-short-order places up to Michelin starred) the most obvious point would be that commercial kitchens are simply packed with testosterone. The most vibrantly male places I've ever been in, in fact, and I used to play rugby too. Anthony Bourdain's “Kitchen Confidential” is excellent on this point. No one has a problem with women in such a kitchen as long as they act as some parody of the worst sort of male, and he really does have a point there.
So there is that point, commercial kitchens are not, to put it mildly, comforting embraces of femininity. Could be simply the sub-culture of the business sector, could be that full service on a busy day is the sort of stressful environment that men -- or maleness -- thrives better in.
Which is one way of thinking about this. But we always need to be careful about statistical evidence. The numbers can tell us that something is happening but not the reason why something is happening. That always needs interpretation -- that story that is so important to us humans.
So, another one. True, Larry Summers lost his job as President of Harvard for even suggesting this but it's still worthy of consideration. When asked why men outnumbered women among the really senior professors, his response was, in effect: Well, that's humans for you. More specifically, aside from things like muscle strength, the averages for men and women are pretty similar for most things. But the variation around the average is much greater for males than females. So, if you're looking for the last 0.0001% of humanity -- senior Harvard professors -- then you're going to end up with more men than women.
This is also true of searching out those with enough brain cells to remain alive but to do no more than that. Both genius and cretin are more common among men than women -- a wider variation from that mean.
The point here is not that either story is necessarily correct -- despite my fondness for that of Larry Summers (this even despite my own determined mediocrity and non-membership of those male extremes). It is, rather, to point out that the “why” is what we need to understand before we try to change anything. If we spot some seeming unfairness then great! Let us examine it. But we do need to understand that “why” before we can craft policies to change it.
In the end this is really just that old trope: Correlation is not causation. Correlation, that statistical pattern, can indeed tell us that something is happening. But we need to understand the reason why, the causation, before we can possibly craft a response to the pattern we see.
There are fewer women than men running top-end commercial kitchens. That is absolutely true. But before we march off to spit-roast those who hire executive chefs we need to understand why this is so. Which is where life becomes that much more difficult. It could indeed be the ingrained sexism of commercial kitchens -- I'd certainly buy into the idea that kitchens are like that. It could be that simply fewer women are interested in that hothouse atmosphere. Even when we think about the few hundred top people in the world who do any common thing (like cooking), the greater male variability comes into play. But we'd really better nail down the “why” before we take action to try to correct it.
We've got to get the story right, that is. For that's how us humans work, the story about the “why.”
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.