Hawks soaring after Bannon's departure

Stephen Bannon may have been a political adviser to President Donald Trump, but his firing Friday could have an impact on US foreign policy from Europe to the Middle East and Asia.

Bannon's exit clears an obstacle for backers of an active US foreign policy in line with recent presidencies — and is a resounding win for Bannon’s internal rival, national security adviser H R McMaster.

Bannon was a regular participant in national security debates, often as an opponent of military action and a harsh critic of international bodies like the United Nations and the European Union.

He has also been a withering critic of diplomatic, military and intelligence professionals—“globalists” he says have repeatedly shown bad judgement, particularly when it comes to US military interventions abroad. That put him at loggerheads with Defence Secretary James Mattis and Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, as well as McMaster.

“If you look at the balance of power of isolationists versus internationalists in the White House now, it seems safe to say that the pendulum has swung towards the internationalists,” said Danielle Pletka, senior vice president for foreign and defence policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute.

Though Bannon has not described himself as an “isolationist,” he has proudly adopted Trump’s “America First” motto, which he says argues for spending less blood and treasure overseas for anything less than America’s most vital interests.

He has also alarmed European leaders with his criticism of the EU and his expressed support for some European nationalist movements. Bannon actively backed Great Britain’s 2016 “Brexit” from the EU and introduced Trump to its chief political advocate, the populist British politician Nigel Farage.

Impact on US foreign policy

In the immediate term, foreign policy insiders agreed, Bannon’s departure also could increase the chances of a US troop increase in Afghanistan—a plan championed by McMaster but strongly opposed by Bannon, who managed to draw out debate on the issue with direct appeals to Trump.

More generally, it will remove an internal brake on US military action abroad. Bannon has argued greater US intervention in Iraq and Syria and was among the few White House officials to oppose President Donald Trump’s early-April missile strike in Syria.

Bannon is not totally conflict averse: He calls for a far stronger US posture against China and has warned that war with Beijing could be inevitable. But he pressed Trump to take economic, not military action against Beijing.

And on Wednesday, Bannon told the American Prospect magazine that there is “no military solution” to Trump’s standoff with North Korea—undermining the president’s recent military threats against that country, and echoing China’s view of the situation.

Beyond the policy realm, Bannon’s exit is a clear victory for national security adviser H R McMaster, who at times seemed to be in zero-sum struggle with the Trump adviser for power and influence in the White House.

Foreign policy veterans were startled when, in early February, Trump designated Bannon as a member of the National Security Council’s elite principals committee—calling it unprecedented for a White House political adviser to have a reserved seat at the table for life-and-death debates.

McMaster stripped Bannon of his official NSC position in April, after succeeding the ousted Michael Flynn—a Bannon ally—as national security adviser. Bannon continued to attend NSC meetings and debates about foreign policy in the Oval Office. But Bannon resented McMaster for demoting him, and for purging several Flynn allies from the NSC.

Bannon and McMaster also sharply differed on how Trump should discuss terrorist groups like IS and al-Qaeda. Bannon favours using the phrase “radical Islamic extremism,” but McMaster has largely prevented Trump from saying it in public on the grounds that it could alienate moderate Muslims who hear it as an attack on their religion.

McMaster’s defenders have accused Bannon of spearheading a campaign of leaks meant to undermine the top national security aide.

Some sources downplayed the significance of Bannon’s departure, however—noting that, on military and diplomatic issues, Bannon was more dissenter than policy maker.

And several sources cautioned that while Bannon may not longer occupy the White House, his worldview is still frequently reflected in the words of the most powerful policymaker of all: President Trump.

[This is an excerpt of a Politico article]