What’s mine is yours too

In November, a news report titled “Mighty Teesta turning into a narrow channel” caught my eye. Parts of that article, which was an especially interesting read: “Teesta, the second largest river in Gaibandha, is drying up quickly and the drastic fall in its water level is impacting agriculture, communication systems, employment and ecology in the region. 
 
Officials of Bangladesh Water Development Board said the water level started falling sharply in September and now most of the river has dried up at an alarming rate, leading to a number of chars forming on the riverbed. 
 
People living by the riverbanks attribute the present situation to the unilateral construction by India of a barrage at Gazoldoba over the Teesta, around 100km upstream of the Teesta Barrage Irrigation Project (TBIP) at Dalia of Lalmonirhat district.
 
The char dwellers have urged the government to take up necessary measures to resume the navigability and water flow in the river and continue it all the year round by rolling on the water sharing treaty with India as early as possible.”
 
The reason why this report caught my eye is, just a few days before it was published, I attended a two-week dialogue between India and Bangladesh, where the topic of discussion was “trans-boundary water resources management.”
 
The Joint River Commission
Throughout the multidimensional talk that was attended by 20 young scholars from both the countries, the most engaging issue for me was the Joint River Commission (JRC). As I listened to the on-going discussions, one question kept bothering me: was the JRC truly a “joint” collaboration? Or was it just a controversial, pro-government institution? 
 
This cloud of confusion started clearing during the second week of the dialogue, held in BRAC CDM, Savar, where Prof Asif Nazrul, from the Department of Law, Dhaka University, criticised JRC’s limited mandate. 
 
“JRC members are government officials. They cannot protest against the government’s decisions,” he said.
 
“There is a provision for appointing a technocrat honorary member in JRC. Dr Ainun Nishat [Vice Chancellor of BRAC University and a member of the government negotiating team on the Teesta issue in 1989] had been one. But, during the last regime of government, they did not appoint any such member. Some JRC members told me that India was not agreeable whenever Bangladesh wanted to appoint any local expert, although there were some proposals from Bangladesh’s side during the last tenure of BNP to appoint a neutral independent expert,” he added.
 
Both sides of the coin
In order to know the other side’s story, I approached Ritwick Dutta, an environmental activist and advocate at the Supreme Court of India, who also attended the dialogue. He said: “No country in the world would ever give the decision making authority to water resource specialists. They may be a part of the team, but ultimately the ministry of water resources, the prime minister’s office, or the ministry of foreign affairs would decide. The ministry of water resources will be at the prime to negotiate or appear to negotiate.
 
“These are the issues that affect security of the whole region. Therefore, ultimately the policy decisions will be taken by bureaucrats and diplomats. Engineers come second in the policy making structure.”
 
A source in JRC Bangladesh alleged that they wanted to build a sub-regional framework. For instance, the Brahmaputra basin is shared by Nepal, Bhutan, China, India and Bangladesh. Therefore, they wanted to engage Nepal and Bhutan in the negotiation. 
 
“But India was highly against it. They said they would negotiate with us, or other countries, separately,” the source claimed, preferring to be anonymous.
 
Dutta had more to add in this regard: “If you look at the river system, you will find that interest of Bangladesh and Nepal are completely different. For example, Nepal will be interested in building more storage dams, which will restrict the flow into India, whereas India would want to make more diversion channels that will affect the movement to the lower riparian country. Nepal is upstream of India and Bangladesh is the lowest. So how do we merge the interest of all three?
 
“I personally do not understand what can be the issues of common interest between Nepal and Bangladesh. I can see commonalities between India, Bhutan and Nepal, because they are the upstream Himalayan states.”
 
He also said a multi-lateral agreement was highly unlikely. “In our current geo-political situation, there is no way that Bangladesh would be able to convince India to involve Nepal. The answer will be ‘no’, for a simple reason that it would complicate the discussion which no one wants,” he added.
 
What the JRC statute entails
A sub-divisional engineer of JRC Bangladesh, seeking anonymity, claimed that, though the statute indicates to hold at least two joint meetings a year, only 37 meetings have been held since the JRC was formed in 1972. The regular meetings are always postponed by the Indian counterpart. In June last year, India cancelled the regular meeting at the last minute because of “unavoidable circumstance.”
 
“The number of meetings depends on timing and willingness. Two countries might be at different political stages at a time. It may not be a national election in India, but it can be a ‘panchayet’ election in Calcutta, a state election in West Bengal or in Delhi. In such circumstances, India will not be willing to hold a meeting,” Dutta said.
 
At this point, I realised that on the surface, the problem deals with a river treaty that has to be signed by Sheikh Hasina, Manmohan Singh, and Mamta Banerjee, but remains strangulated because of the age-old artless negotiation with a tremendous lack of coordination.
 
Prof Nazrul pointed out that in the previous agreements shared by the two countries, in the Ganges Water treaty, for example, there was no mention of the word “pollution” – an issue that is comprehensively talked about in all European and American water sharing treaties. 
 
Drawing examples from different global laws, like the UN Watercourses Convention 1997 and Helsinki Rules, Nazrul mentioned a number of factors to define “equitable utilisation” including population, impact of the project in the area, available alternatives, etc.
 
What’s next?
The demand of time, it seems, is for Bangladesh and India to revive the JRC statute and meet as frequently as possible. It’s high time to take the voices of people living on the basin of Teesta into account. 
 
However, Bangladesh also needs to remember that ours is the lowest riparian country and gets extremely less amounts of water during the lean period. For example, Teesta flows 60bcm (billion cubic metres) year round, whereas, during the lean period, which is September to May, the flow reduces to only 5bcm. If we want “equitable utilisation” of water that ensures rightful share of all the stakeholders, we should know that farmers are the ones who actually know where and what quantum of water flows at different points of the year. So they should be heard through representatives. The think tanks and technical experts have to consider the local interest.