Putting a price tag on it

A coalition of Bangladeshi women’s groups has demanded that unpaid household work should be included in GDP. They are wrong in this demand simply because of the way we define gross domestic product in the first place. And yet we do indeed value that work and perhaps we should thus apply a monetary value to it. But the solution isn’t going to be one those campaigners are going to like very much. In truth, GDP itself isn’t all that good a measure. What we are trying to do is measure the value added in an economy -- for what we consume is value. Thus, what is produced is what can be consumed. If more is produced then we are richer in aggregate. GDP doesn’t measure who gets to do the consuming despite that being something that interests us all, and as Keynes said when the concept was first introduced, when a man marries his housekeeper -- it falls. For, as the afore-mentioned women are complaining, only paid services -- monetised activities -- are included, and not unpaid household work. Photo: Bigstock But then that’s just what GDP is -- the value of monetised transactions. This problem has been known about since the very start of the measure. Indeed it was mentioned by Simon Kuznets, the original designer of the concept. And yet we still stick with it because GDP is something most useful -- it is objective. We don’t measure that value added by what we think it should be or what it ought to be. We measure it by what people actually do pay money for -- that’s why we use market prices. So it’s not what the businessman thinks his products are worth, not whatever value the bureaucrat might apply to his activities, but what consumers are willing to pay for them in a market transaction. We thus get an objective view of how people do value these things and thus can reach that objective measure of how well off we all are. The really big problem though is that it doesn’t measure what we would really like to know, which is how well off do the people think they are. For example, we must value the things we buy at more than they cost us -- if we didn’t, we wouldn’t buy them. We can also look at this the other way around, the tea seller knows that one of two of his customers will pay more for their chai than others. But he doesn’t know which ones, thus has to charge a standard price to all. Those who would pay more but do not have to thus get something of a bargain, and we call that the consumer surplus. This is the thing that we’re really interested in -- what value do people think they’re getting --and that is the precise thing that GDP does not and cannot measure. And since we have no other way of finding out, we just generally assume that it’s about the same as the number we can calculate. If GDP is $1 billion then consumer surplus is $1 billion and the total value everyone’s getting is $2 billion. There’s a lot of this sort of hand waving in economics I’m afraid. Women’s labour most definitely has value and should be included in that consumer surplus even if it’s not in GDP. Mother’s cooking and wifely attentions to a husband are things that people enjoy after all. They can be monetised, as the existence of restaurants and Kandapara prove, but they’re not in general. So we face a problem of how to value it. This being a problem that the Sarkozy Commission, working for the then French president, and including the Nobel Laureates Joe Stiglitz and Amartya Sen, tried to explore. They made Adam Smith’s point, that market work, that we’re paid for, allows us to divide and specialise our labour. We become more efficient, more productive, at the specific task that we do, and this makes the society as a whole richer, for more is being produced, more value is being added, with each hour of human labour. But for household work this isn’t so -- unless lifestyles are rather more racy than most of us manage, there are only two adults in a family. We can thus do rather less dividing and specialising than we can out in that market economy of 7 billion people. So that household labour is rather unproductive when compared to paid, market labour. The result being that they said that household labour should be valued at the “undifferentiated wage rate.” Which to the rest of us means minimum wage. Or, as it might be in Bangladesh, some Tk 2-3,000 a month. Which is where the real problem is in this demand that women’s household work be included in GDP. No, not that it violates economic principles, rather, that your mother, who conceived, carried, bore, suckled, trained you and even now drops hints wondering when the grandchildren will arrive, you’ve now got to go and tell her that all those years of her labour are valued at about what a rickshaw driver gets a month. It’s easier just to say that including household labour in GDP violates some economic principle or other, isn’t it?
 Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.