Our organisation, your organisation
Publish : 16 Sep 2017, 23:53
In December 2010, there were lot of disquieting developments happening around me. I was almost pushed to the corner to put in my papers at Citibank. My management teachers and few corporate well-wishers thought I had succumbed to the pressure from insiders or company long-timers. Even with nine years gone, I was not able to gel with my work.
Surprisingly when my successor, and a long-timer in the same bank, had to leave after 22 years, corridor discussions said people joining from other organisations who were enjoying the upper-hand made it happen. Every large organisation in this world has a distinctive culture, which identifies them from the other. We often get to hear: “It does not work here or we do it differently.”
Edgar Schein, a former professor at the MIT Sloan School of Management, defines organisational culture as “a pattern of shared basic assumptions that was learned by a group as it solved its problems of external adaptation and internal integration, that has worked well enough to be considered valid and, therefore, to be taught to new members as the correct way you perceive, think, and feel in relation to those problems.”
My favorite definition would be this one-liner by Deal and Kennedy: “The way things get done around here.”
Suppose you join a new organisation at the top management level. You start by studying the hard numbers but don’t get too bogged down. The most important aspect of the organisation a leader must realise is the culture.
The most powerful people in the organisation are not necessarily the ones at the top. People exercise unofficial powers through informal groups, grapevines, and personal relationships nurtured through all their corporate lives. The corporate world is, after all, a human world. Once you understand the salient features of the prevailing culture, there is really no point ignoring, denying, or even fighting it.
Replace the weak features with the best practices shared by other organisations and reward people accordingly. Once you establish the right culture into place, the business results will follow suit automatically with lesser efforts.
There was an old research done by NASA, the findings of which still hold: “The stereotypical take-charge ‘flyboy’ pilots, who acted immediately on their gut instincts, made the wrong decisions far more often than the more open, inclusive pilots who said to their crews, in effect, ‘we’ve got a problem. How do you read it?’ before choosing a course of action.”
The findings also suggested that “the pilots who’d made the right choices routinely had open exchanges with their crew members.” It shows that top-down organisational leadership/culture is a must-have these days, but it should also empower the management and incorporate the employees’ perspective.
The organisations which trusted and empowered its employees reaped those benefits in crucial times.
In 2009, when most companies with business in the US were trying to tackle the toll of recession, they had to go for a mass lay-offs, be it gradual or one-time, raising the rate of unemployment drastically year on year. What amazed me was that Hewlett-Packard opted for a pay cut at all levels to save a portion of the employees from being laid off.
In Bangladesh, Standard Chartered acquired ANZ Grindlays bank in 2001. ANZ was the largest foreign bank, while StanChart was the smartest. Seniors, therefore, termed this as a “merger of equals” instead of acquisition. The CEO came from ANZ, while the client relationship head, risk head, corporate affairs head, and chief financial officer came from StanChart.
The first year was spent integrating the hearts of the people and the clients, and ensure regulatory compliance. Though, looking quite alike, the two institutions were quite different in their core culture.
Citibank NA decided to give a chance to “change” to focus more on revenue, branding, and keeping clients happy. A dream team was built up, under direct sponsorship of the seniors in India, Hong Kong, and New York. The existing people felt overridden. Clients grew, revenue multiplied, all stakeholders started to appreciate the visibility brought in through all the right works.
But the disconnect in chemistry between the old guards and new never went away. It was almost after 10 years all the “change drivers” found them in orphanage, while most of the sponsors were gone due to North America meltdown.
The hardliners got into the command controls and the outcome is up for anyone to guess: All the brand builders had left. Things had changed by 180 degrees after six years. For good or bad, we don’t know.
Mamun Rashid is a leading banker and economic analyst.