Canopy Growth (NASDAQ: CGC) (TSE: WEED) stock was down yet another 10% yesterday on the announcement of the results. These can vaguely be described as better but still not good. The did manage to reduce losses, a bit, but at the expense of falling revenue. So they’re not, not exactly, growing the trade to match their cost base which is the thing we’d rather like to see happening.
The results themselves: “Canadian cannabis business delivered its third consecutive quarter of organic revenue growth while significantly reducing costs. Achieved Q2 FY2024 net revenue of $70 MM. Consolidated gross margin was 34% in Q2 FY2024, compared to (1%) in Q2 FY2023, primarily driven by the business transformation initiatives executed since the beginning of FY2023. Delivered additional cost reduction of $54 MM in Q2 FY2024, bringing the total cost reduction to $226 MM since the beginning of FY2023. Management is tightening its previously announced cost reduction target to $270 MM – $300 MM by the end of FY2024. With the completed sale of the Company's Hershey Drive facility, generated aggregate gross proceeds of approximately $155 MM from facilities sales since April 1, 2023. Reduced overall debt by $364 MM to $681 MM in Q2 FY2024; total debt reduction of approximately $1 BN delivered since the beginning of FY2023.”
That claim of organic growth is slightly odd, in that they’re counting growth in the bits of the business they retained, even as overall turnover fell as they sold assets and a business line.
Canopy Growth stock price from Google Finance
There was that excitement two months back in Canopy Growth: “Canopy Growth (NASDAQ: CGC) (TSE: WEED) stock is up some 85% in the last few days. This is on the back of varied stories about possible Federal legalisation of cannabis. There are mutterings of all sorts of things. Apparently Joe Biden has “always” supported some move. Chuck Schumer has been talking about changing the Schedule. That wouldn’t be legalisation but it would enable firms to deduct certain business expenses which they cannot now. Or those mutterings about the Safe Banking Act. This is all an advance in a legal and even civilisational aspect. For, yes, of course weed should be legalised. “ As we can see from the stock price chart, that excitement didn’t linger.
As we also said back in July about Canopy Growth: “The other issue is the amount of competition. Far too many people saw all of this happening and decided to pile in. There's just too much capital chasing a market too small for it. At which point no one makes any money out of it. We don't think that any of this is going to change in the immediate future. Not until most of the hopefuls go bust and there's a clear out of the supply side of the market.”
We’re simply bear the entire market, as we’ve also said about Aurora Cannabis. We simply do not see anyone building a premium market position out of something as simple to grow as cannabis sativa. A bulk business based on lowest cost production in Africa, maybe, but not someone producing in N America. Just cannot see how the numbers would work out there.