Works Co (LON: WRKS) shares are down 28% today. WRKS shares dropping near a third is, of course, an indication of what is happening to that retail business. However, we think it’s also possible to take this as an indication of something rather more serious.
The announcement: “In the first half of FY24 The Works delivered total sales growth of 3.4% and a total LFL sales increase of 1.6%. Store LFLs increased by 3.5%, whilst online sales declined by 12.2%. The macro-economic environment was challenging throughout the period, characterised by high inflation and low consumer confidence. In the nine weeks since our previous update, consumer demand has softened further” and “We anticipate that trading conditions during H2 FY24 will remain challenging and consumer spend will be subdued, resulting in the continuation of the increased levels of discounting recently seen across the sector.”
Now, they’re going to advertise more to try to beat this. Which doesn;t bode well for margins of course - more discounting means less revenue, more “promotional activity” means higher costs. So, margins tighten once again.
Works Co Uk share price from Google Finance
The thing that really worries us here though is along that canary in the coal mine line. For it’s a standard observation among economists that we near never know that we’ve been in a recession until it’s pretty much over. That is, our warning signs of a recession in the economic statistics work historically, not in advance. Corporate results like these are also historical - we’re being told that retail has been slow this past 9 weeks for example. That’s not something that will really show up in GDP yet. It’s when the factories making stuff slow down - because the retail distribution chain is still full of things unsold as yet - that we do start to see a recession in the usual economic numbers.
It’s also true that we tend to see those numbers around and about the time that the retail destocking comes to an end - that’s just how long the statistical process lasts. Agreed, that all sounds a little odd but that really is how economists think about it.
So, we’re reading three - and it’s not just this one company - slowdowns in retail sales as being evidence of a possible recession. No, not that we’re about to have one but that we are in one already, we just don’t know it.
Now, if that’s true - and it’s a supposition only, not a fact - then our activities in stock markets should be trades only, not investments. Short term ins and outs - because supposing that recession is here then long term buys are about to get cheaper.