Li Ning (HKG: 2331) shares are up 6.5% today. Only a week back Li Ning reported a lowered forecast for sales this year. That led to a 20% fall in the share price: “Li Ning (HKG: 2331) shares are down 20% on their report of falling sales numbers. Not a fall in actual sales you understand, instead a fall in the growth of those numbers. In fact, given inflation, we’d probably say a fall in real sales while still a growth in nominal: “The Beijing-based company said Wednesday after the market closed that its third-quarter retail sales registered a mid-single-digit percentage increase. That is lower than market expectations of growth in the teens,” As ever, it’s not what the actual performance is that matters to the share price. It’s whatever gap there is between expectations and reality that moves the share price. What we think is going to happen is already in the share price - that it’s not going to happen is the new information that moves it.”
If we expect sales to fall in those real terms - or even if just growth isn’t what we expected it would be - then of course the same price then falls. But this also then works the other way around. If we see a rising share price for a retail and consumer group like Li Ning should we then assume that retail sales are going to increase? Yes, yes, we probably should assume that.
Li Ning share price from Google Finance
One set of thoughts: “The Hong Long-listed sportswear brand Li Ning Co. Ltd. (HK:2331) has garnered multiple Buy recommendations from analysts since its Q3 operational update was released last week. In its third-quarter operational update, the company reduced its full-year guidance due to inventory concerns, causing a 20% drop in its shares in a single day. Despite this, analysts hold a bullish view of the share price, predicting a huge upside of more than 70%.” All of which could be true. But we do tend to look more than a little askance at buy side price recommendations.
This looks more to the point: “China’s recent stimulus boost stoked some optimism about the economy’s recovery in the coming quarters, but economists are keeping their 2024 growth forecasts steady for now to assess how the measures will play out. The world’s second-largest economy is projected to grow 4.5% next year, according to the median estimate in a Bloomberg survey of 48 economists conducted after last week’s official announcement of the additional stimulus.”
The entire point of stimulus is to increase economic activity. Consumer spending is economic activity - it will be increased by stimulus. So it is possible that Li Ning’s predicted sales slowdown is already outpaced by the change in China’s macroeconomic policies toward stimulus.
We’re always a bit wary about stimulus as a macroeconomic policy, it certainly works in the short term and not so often nor so well in the medium to long. But it’ll certainly lift consumer spending in that short term so perhaps the Li Ning reaction is correct.