DBS Group Holdings (SGX: D05) shares are up 2% on the announcement of the trading restrictions the bank must operate under. The cause here is the series of system outages over the months and the regulator has imposed business restrictions until management are able to get matters sorted. Now, of course, the D05 share price movement could be just the bellwether stock moving in line with the market but that would be a boring explanation.
The background here, from our spring piece about DBS Group: “DBS (SGX: DO5) (OTCPK: DBSDF) shares are down 1.19% in Singapore on Friday. More importantly, DBS was the biggest trade on the SGX on Friday by value. The problem is the digital outage suffered by the payments system on Wednesday. That, in itself, isn't really the problem - computer systems fail and, well, computer systems fail. Rather, the problem becomes what will be the reaction of the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) to this problem. For it has happened before and constraints upon DBS followed. So, what will follow from this outage?”
The problems have persisted over time and now we know what MAS has imposed: “The punishment meted out to DBS appears "minor" and not commensurate with the impact of the service disruptions to Singapore's biggest lender, including one where online banking and ATM services were down for hours, analysts said. On Wednesday (Nov 1), the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) said DBS would be barred from making non-essential IT changes and any acquisitions of new business ventures for six months.”
DBS Group Holdings share price from Google Finance
There is also this: ““As an acknowledgement that the bank could have done better, senior management will be held accountable, and this will be reflected in their compensation,” DBS Chairman Peter Seah said in a statement.” And: “The $80 million investment will be channelled into multiple areas aimed at strengthening technology governance, staff and leadership training, as well as enhancing existing systems and procedures.”
There are two ways of looking at this. One is simply relief that the MAS actions were not more onerous. There could have been a significant fine for example. The other is that, well, just how bad are those restrictions? No foreign adventures for 6 months, boost the operational capability of the banking system itself and cut management pay? It’s entirely possible to think that those are all - individually and in aggregate - things which benefit shareholders anyway.
We do tend to think that today’s share price movement is really about the market as a whole. But the absence of a fall given the punishment is, we think, about the generally beneficial effect of those constraints.