PetMed Express (NASDAQ: PETS) stock is down 29%. PETS stock has fallen on the results and the cancellation of the dividend. Well, that happens - but the issue we should take note of here is as an example of what is called the “dividend trap”. Often enough we invest for income. So a stock offering a 12% dividend yield (or 8% perhaps before this price fall) could be very attractive. But that does depend upon the past dividend being maintained into the future. As it hasn’t been which is why it’s called a trap.
The business line: “PetMed Express, Inc., together with its subsidiaries, operates as a pet pharmacy in the United States. The company markets prescription and non-prescription pet medications, health products, and other supplies for dogs, cats, and horses. It offers non-prescription medications and supplies, such as flea and tick control products, bone and joint care products, vitamins, treats, nutritional supplements,” etc. OK, then come the results of that business line: “PetMed Express Inc. (PETS) on Monday reported a loss of $70,000 in its fiscal second quarter.” Which isn't good and is significantly lower than expected. The bigger issue for us here is: “Shares of PetMed Express fell after the company swung to a loss in the second quarter and suspended its quarterly dividend.”
That dividend suspension. If we had bought in for that dividend yield then we’re going to be more than a bit unhappy about it being cancelled.
PetMed Express stock price from Google Finance
Which is where this idea of the dividend trap comes in. So, we’re looking for income, for yield. We spot a high yield, why not buy in for the income? Well, perhaps that dividend isn’t going to be maintained? Well, sure, that could happen, but why should it?
Which is where the trap is. Because the dividend yield is calculated on the past dividend by the current stock price. But if the market thinks that future results are going to be worse then that stock price falls. But we’re still using the historical dividend to calculate the yield. Thus as the market becomes more gloomy about the prospects - and the likelihood of the dividend being maintained falls - then the apparent yield of the stock rises.
Which is exactly what has happened here at PetMed Express. The stock’s down 48% over the year to date. It’s that which has driven up the apparent yield - the historical dividend and the current stock price.
Sure, if we want to invest for income we should be looking at the dividend and the yield. But we also need to avoid that dividend trap, where the yield is apparently high simply because we don’t expect it to be maintained.