TransUnion (NYSE: TRU) down 24% on lowered guidance - a little strange

TransUnion (NYSE: TRU) stock is down 24%. The fall in TRU stock comes from the company’s announcement of Q3 results - which were not, in fact, the problem. What mattered were the predictions for the future. Which makes some sense of course, the net present value of a stock is the discounted value of all future earnings. Those fall and so does the stock value. It is possible to think through this the wrong way though - as we did initially. As the company provides credit services then shouldn’t hard economic times coming increase demand? But that’s not how the US economy does work. Everything is credit checked already, so fewer transactions - that slowing economy - will indeed reduce demand.

The important part of the announcement: “TransUnion shares touched a six-year low after the credit reporting firm cut its annual guidance, citing slowing volumes, and reported a weaker third-quarter performance than analysts had expected….The company said before the bell that it now expects adjusted earnings, which strip out one-time items, of $3.24 to $3.38 a share for 2023, down from its prior forecast for $3.49 to $3.62 a share.”

transunion

TransUnion stock price from Google Finance

The fuller announcement is here: “Total revenue for the quarter was $969 million, an increase of 3 percent (3 percent on a constant currency basis), compared with the third quarter of 2022.” That’s not actually good. Inflation over the past year - and recall, corporate accounts are not inflation adjusted - has been well above 3%. Therefore the compan is, in real terms, shrinking. “Net income (loss) attributable to TransUnion was $(400) million for the quarter, compared with $79 million for the third quarter of 2022.” Which is a major cause of that, he inflation. For of course the costs have all gone up by at least the inflation rate (US wages are growing above inflation for example) while revenues have not. That takes a big bite out of the bottom line.

““TransUnion executed well against weakening lending and marketing activity over the course of the quarter,” As we said above, it’s possible to think that there will be greater demand for credit checking in a worse economy. But the US economy already pretty much credit checks ever transaction (hyperbole but still). Meaning that it’s the gross volume of transactions and market share which determine TransUnion’s revenues. A slowing economy by definition hsa fewer transactions. This is expected to continue: “We are revising our 2023 full-year guidance to account for slowing volumes in the U.S. and United Kingdom.” Which is the thing that really pushed the TRU stock price down. The future’s expected to be worse.