Tirupati Graphite (LON: TGR) shares are up 24% today on the back of the Chinese graphite export restrictions. Given that TGR is one of the few outside China producers of that natural flake graphite so desired by battery anode makers this seems sensible enough. As the company says: “Tirupati expects the combination of increasing demand and supply shortfalls, alongside China's export restrictions, to have a positive impact on Graphite prices which have fallen since the start of 2023. Tirupati also expects that ex-China consumers of Flake Graphite in energy transition sectors and others shall progress their efforts to secure ex-China supply sources for their Flake Graphite needs to mitigate increasing geopolitical risk surrounding it and other critical minerals.” That all seems sensible enough.
However, we should also point out about Tirupati Graphite: “But as we’ve pointed out years back about Tirupati, and also about Northern Graphite, there’s very rarely an absolute shortage of a mineral. As demand rises more people go looking for ways to supply. Just given the size of the planet - and that it’s all made up of only those 90 elements - that means some to many will be able to supply. That means supply increases and therefore there’s pressure on pricing. As Tirupati says: “The price realised remained similar to H1 previous year in spite of subdued market prices during the current year period.” Yep, even with the EV revolution prices are subdued - that means supply is increasing along with demand.” And do note that Tirupati shares dropped 15% last week on the news that their ore grade is worse than first thought.
Tirupati Graphite share price from Google Finance
While we do believe Tirupati’s base contention there - export restrictions might well increase the price and sure, people might well look for secure, non-China, supply we’re less than convinced about the long term. For there is that point we make above. There’s very rarely indeed an absolute shortage of any mineral - especially when it’s possible to make graphite from oil sludge. OK, it’s not natural flake when made that way but still. There’s a substitute for it.
There’re also those two Australian suppliers to think of, Syrah Resources: “We had a look a few months back at Syrah Resources: “Syrah Resources (ASX: SYR) (FRA: 3S7) (OTCPK: SYAAF) shares are down 16% in heavy trade. The SYR share price is declining on the back of their quarterly and half-year results. They've actually had to stop production because no one is buying their lovely natural graphite. Yes, even in the midst of the battery boom they've had problems in shifting battery components. This doesn't really bode well if we think about it.” That’s perhaps not a good sign. “ Yes, agreed, the market has recently been in oversupply and now, possibly, it isn’t going to be. But that does tell us something about the potential supply of graphite. As does the other Oz company, Renascor Resources: “As we’ve said before about Renascor Resources: “Renascor Resources (ASX: RNU) (OTCPK: RSNUF) shares are down 22%. RNU shares dropped on the presentation of the Siviour Battery Anode project plans. Which is a bit odd as that report shows that it’s value creating, profitable and they’ve even already got much of the finance to be getting along with. All of those are things we’d like to see in a plan so the idea that the shares become worth less upon its presentation is odd.”
Tirupati will, clearly, benefit from any reduction in Chinese exports. But the idea of an absolute shortage - or even of a soaring price rather than a mildly improved one - seems unlikely to us. Simply because there’s a lot of graphite out there.