Capricorn Energy (LON: CNE) 56p dividend, 3 for 2 consolidation - investors are stupid

Capricorn Energy (LON: CNE) shares should - if the company has got its calculations right - not change in price at all this morning. CNE shares will change because those calculations are bound to be not quite right. But it’s worth understanding what the calculations are.

We should start with this idea, something passed at the general meeting: “Pursuant to the Q4 Return of Cash, Capricorn will pay a special dividend of 56 pence per existing ordinary share amounting to a return of approximately US$100 million (c.£79.09 million) to Shareholders” Which is great, of course. The purpose of a company is to give money to shareholders. One a £1.70 share, 56 pence each is pretty good. They’ve got enough capital from previous success to do that, we get it back. Cool even. We can then invest that as we choose - even, in renewables if we want to switch from oil to that sector.

However, this then runs up against the number illusion. If we sit down and really think about our investments then in the future we’ll not that the Capricorn share price falls as it pays out a special dividend. So, no matter - in fact we might think better of CNE and bid the price up because of that possibility of special capital returns. But the average market estimation is that we don’t think that way. That we do not include capital returns in our estimations of where to invest next.

Capricorn Energy share price from Google Finance

Instead we look at share price charts and do not take account of those details. Therefore there’s another part to this: “The Share Consolidation will reduce the number of Capricorn’s issued ordinary shares by an amount that reflects the value of the Q4 Return of Cash to Shareholders relative to the market capitalisation of Capricorn prior to the Q4 Return of Cash. As such, every 3 existing ordinary shares of 490/143 pence each will be replaced by 2 new ordinary shares of 735/143 pence each (subject to fractional entitlements) so as to reduce the number of shares in issue to reflect the amount of cash to be returned to Shareholders.”

The entire point of this is to produce a - relatively - smooth share price chart unadjusted for that capital return. They simply do not believe that we, as future investors, will account for that 56p capital return on our estimations.

They might even be right. But that’s what’s going on here. An assumption that as investors we are not wholly rational when viewing prices. As we say, maybe they’re right but it’s a slightly depressing thought that they could be.