Cosmos Exploration (ASX: C1X) down 46% - lovely geologic results but no actual lithium

Cosmos Exploration (ASX: C1X) shares are down 46% today. This decline in C1X shares comes from their release of a lovely announcement, full of excitement over the geology - but an absence of any actual lithium yet found. Which seems a fair enough reaction to us, the aim of the game is to find lithium not lovely geology.

That announcement: “Preliminary assays received from surface sampling at Corvette Far East (CFE) return highly elevated lithium and beryllium as well as critical characteristic low K/Rb ratios and high caesium confirming the presence of extremely fractionated pegmatites close to a potentially large spodumene system. • Preliminary mineralogy work and consultation with lithium pegmatite experts confirm the presence of diagnostic highly fractionated lithium-caesium-tantalum minerals such as petalite and unusually lithium-caesium-rich beryl, further supporting the interpretation that Polaris is a highly fractionated rare metal pegmatite on the outer edge of an LCT pegmatite field.” And so on and so on.

An important line though: “In addition to the rock assays, X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) analysis was also completed on sample H909418 in order to establish the mineralogy of that sample given the unusually high levels of key LCT metals including 1,647 ppm Li2O,” Which is 0.16% LiO2. Or not anywhere close to being economic. Another important line “ The results suggest the primary mineral is an unusually lithium- and caesium-rich beryl variety with visual characteristics incredibly similar to spodumene. The XRD analysis also confirms the presence of the lithium ore mineral petalite. Both minerals are known to occur in a highly evolved and fractionated rare metal pegmatite field in very close proximity to and overlapping the spodumene field.”

So the real message here is that maybe there’s a lithium containing spodumene deposit around here but we’ve not found it as yet. Which is not, as the Cosmos share price shows, a greatly value enhancing statement.

Cosmos Exploration share price from Google Finance

We’ve looked before at Cosmos Exploration: “Cosmos Exploration (ASX: C1X) shares are up 30% after they report finding the one piece of rock. A chip in fact. Sure, the chip contains rare earths and even a decent concentration of scandium. But the one rock chip is a small piece of evidence to base a $7 million change in market capitalisation - even in those bijou Australian dollars. OK, perhaps we’re being a little unfair as of course finding evidence of at least some rare earths is better than finding evidence of nothing at all interesting. But it is true that there’s still a long way to go here.” That share price rise faded pretty quickly too.

About the most positive thing it’s possible to say here is that Cosmos isn’t barred from finding an economic deposit in the future but it hasn’t done so yet.