Peloton (NASDAQ: PTON) is up 16% on the announcement of a deal with Lululemon (NASDAQ: LULU). At first glance the deal is strikingly attractive. Which is probably why Peloton stock jumped 50% on the announcement. PTON stock then dropped back to only 16% up by the end of the aftermarket trading. That’s because while the deal is, on that first look, that strikingly attractive it’s not obvious that it will entirely work out.
So we know what each business does. Peloton runs those online exercise classes, sells the equipment and subscriptions to do them on. This business soared in lockdown and has had considerable problems since. They expanded far too much into that explosion of lockdown demand and then got caught out with overstock and a grossly bloated overhead when demand fell back to more rational levels as the world opened up again. Lululemon is best known for those leggings which larger women should perhaps not try to wear. But they also provide exercise classes and so on. Retail is a larger part of the business than the classes.
The deal is that Peloton takes on the classes side of the business, Lululemon the clothing side for both. OK, there’s a lot more detail than that but that’s the gist of it. The advantage is that neither now has to carry the overhead of the minor parts of their business while still being able to make revenue from it. They’ve each sliced off a considerable cost base that is - excellent. As it’s Peloton currently with the financial problems the effect on stock prices is concentrated there.
Peloton stock price from Google Finance
The bounce in the PTON stock price is therefore easily explained. It’s the fade back that needs thinking about. One possible answer is simply that markets often enough do get over-excited on a piece of news. A flurry of speculation and then a bit of a rethink. That’s possible.
But it’s also possible that the rethink has a deeper cause to it. To some extent Peloton is a failing brand. And clever distribution moves - and this can indeed be described as clever - don’t really revive brands. Because it’s the brand which is the valuable thing and if that’s damaged, well, that’s the thing of value damaged. It’s even possible to go one stage further and think that the whole idea of those online exercise classes is now out of fashion. Which would lead to the thought that Lululemon has very much the better part of the deal here as they’ve got rid of that part of their business. While Peloton loses the branded althleisurewear business which seems to still have legs.
No, we don’t know which way prices are going to go when the market opens fully today. But it’s not obvious that even this premium will remain on the Peloton stock.