Delta Corp (NSE: DELTACORP) down 17% - an insane tax demand, wholly stupid

Delta Corp (NSE: DELTACORP) shares are down  17% in India today. Note that this is Delta the Indian casino operator, not Delta the American airline. The cause of this is the entirely insane tax demand the company has just received. The only reason the shares are not lower again, to something under nothing, is because the tax demand is so ludicrous that it’s obvious that it’s not going to be paid. Paying it would not just bankrupt Delta Corp, it would make any continuance of any form of gambling in India impossible.

Few of us think that politicians are all that smart and yes, obviously, they do sometimes pass silly laws. What we don’t know here is whether it’s the law itself or the interpretation given by the tax office. But there really are only two possible results here. Delta - and all other gaming companies in India - go bust or the taxman’s interpretation of the law is changed. Got to be one or the other, there is no middle road here. 

The event itself at Delta Corp: “Delta Corp shares fell nearly 20% to their 52-week low of Rs 140 on the NSE in Monday's early trade following a notice from the government to pay tax of Rs 11,140 crore along with interest and penalty for the period July 2017 to March 2022. The tax payment notice to the company exceeds its current market capitalisation of Rs 4,228.10 crore.” Wanting more in tax than the total value of the company is one of those things that just isn’t going to happen.

r

Delta Corp share price from Google Finance

The silliness - actually, the idiocy - is: “The tax notice comes at a time when the company, valued at over $566 million, is already facing heat over the recent move in July by the country's Goods and Services Tax (GST) Council to impose a 28% indirect tax on the money collected by gaming companies from customers. The GST amount claimed is based on the gross bet value of all games played at the casinos during the relevant period, Delta said, adding that a show cause notice will be issued to the company if it failed to pay.” As we say, that’s an insane way of trying to tax gaming and casino companies.

GST - or VAT - on net revenues, the amount the casino keeps after paying out winnings, that could work. But gross revenues? Nope, never going to work in the slightest. It’s not just that Delta can’t pay this amount, it’s that if that is the GST law then no one will gamble in casinos. For it means a 28% tax on each and every betting stake - not betting winnings, but on each stake. Which is absurd. 

Now, given that this is Indian politics and tax we’re talking about this could go either way. But the tax demand is insane.