Charger Metals (ASX: CHR) shares are down 26% today. CHR shares fell because, amazingly, they failed to find good and economic amounts of lithium. Given that everyone and their Granny seems to be able to find some by checking the flowerbeds in the back garden what went wrong? Well, yes, OK, we might be employing more than a little hyperbole there but even so - there are lots of lithium finds happening, this isn’t one of them.
The announcement itself: “However, the fractionation within the lithiumcaesium-tantalum (“LCT”) pegmatites is not homogeneous, with the spodumene content of the pegmatite intersections inconsistent and low-grade.“ That’s not good news. Some of the numbers, even where they have found lithium, are not good - 0.4, maybe 0.5% and so on, not normally thought of as economic numbers. Yes, this is early days, yes this could still work out, but the results so far probably do justify that fall in the share price.
Charger Metals share price from Google Finance
What we think is more important here is the reminder to us that some of the claims by other lithium exploration companies also might not work out. For consider this: “Charger Metals NL (ASX: CHR, “Charger” or the “Company”) reports that it has received the majority of the outstanding assay results from the drilling completed at the Bynoe Lithium Project, Northern Territory, adjacent to the Finniss Lithium Mine owned by Core Lithium Ltd (ASX:CXO).” Part of the idea here was that as the next property over has lithium then so might this one. And that can be true, yes, geologic features can run through and over mining claim boundaries.
But clearly enough and obviously enough that’s not always true - otherwise we’d have the same minerals everywhere, if all geologies ran for ever. We don’t, so they don’t. OK, that’s obvious - but there are a number of companies exploring on this very same basis. That bit over there has lithium so maybe our bit does too? Raiden Resources, Sabre, and that’s just the first two we think of who are running off the more confirmed finds by Azure at Andover.
Yes, it’s entirely true that lithium is, these days, the very thing. Also that exploring near where others have found lithium is a sensible enough idea. But as here at Charger Metals, it doesn't always work. So apply the appropriate discount to the hopes of those using the same tactics.