Pointsbet Holdings (ASX: PBH) (OTCQX: PBTHF) shares are down 55%. PBH shares falling 55% should not though, be seen as an actual fall in the share price. Yes, we know this is a slightly complex way of thinking about things but this is actually a share price rise. If a company returns capital to shareholders then the true price is the capital returned plus the remaining value of the shares themselves. Which is what has happened here, a capital return. And yes, the combination of the two does in fact mean that this is a rise in the PBH total share price.
We’ve talked before about Pointsbet: “Pointsbet Holdings (ASX: PBH) (OTCQX: PBTHF) shares have dropped 21% in Australia today. We'd expect much the same reaction on the OTC market in the US when that opens. The cause here is that as has been known for some time Pointsbet desires to get out of its US operations. The competition and thus capital demands are simply too high to be able to continue to try to expand. We've also known for a bit that Fanatics was the likely buyer. What's happened today is that the actual terms have come through. Not as good as some were gambling upon them being.”
That was four months back. The PBH share price has not done well since then and there was that fall as the terms of the deal came through. However, this latest fall in the price is actually a rise:
Pointsbet Holdings share price from Google Finance
The reason is this announcement: “Applicable security for the return of capital PBH - ORDINARY FULLY PAID Announcement Type New announcement Date of this announcement 1/9/2023 Return of Capital amount per security AUD 1.00000000”
Everyone who had one PBH share yesterday - valued at $1,65 - today has $1 plus one share of PBH - valued at $0.75. Today’s value is $1,75 as opposed to yesterday’s of $1,65. That’s a rise in the share price overall.
The other way of putting this is that the capital distribution is $1 while the share price drop is $0.91. That’s a $0.09 increase in value (the two methods do not quite agree because of rounding).
That capital received from the Fanatics deal gets passed back to shareholders. The net result of this is that a 55% fall in the Pointsbet share price is actually a rise in shareholder wealth - or a rise in the PBH share price.