Instem (LON: INS) up 40% on bid - no, don’t bother, nothing left in it

Instem (LON: INS) shares are up 40% this morning on the back of a bid for the company. INS shares could - potentially that is - be worth picking up if there’s a gap between that offer price and the current market one. There is such a gap, a small one, but it’s not worth trying to arbitrage the bid. The price difference, after we take account of the spread on the shares, is such that we’d be better off leaving our money in a deposit account. Sad but there it is.

Instem’s announcement: “The board of directors of Ichor Management Limited ("Bidco") and the board of directors of Instem plc ("Instem") are pleased to announce that they have reached agreement on the terms of a recommended cash offer to be made by Bidco for the entire issued and to be issued ordinary share capital of Instem (the "Acquisition"). It is intended that the Acquisition will be implemented by way of a scheme of arrangement under Part 26 of the Companies Act. Under the terms of the Acquisition, each Instem Shareholder will be entitled to receive: 833 pence in cash per Instem Share

r

Instem share price from Google Finance

Clearly we’d like to have bought yesterday at 590 but sadly the news of the bid did not leak so we weren’t alerted. And, of course, if the news had leaked then the price would not have been 590. That’s just how these things work out.

But we might think that as the bid price is 833 and the current market is 825 then there’s a little profit to be had. A guaranteed one in fact. Sure, 8 pence isn’t much but it is a positive return. The thing is that we can’t in fact buy at 825. That’s the mid price. The spread is actually 820 to 830. Meaning we’d have to buy at 830. Then hold and get our 833 when the deal finally closes. That’s a 0.3% return and we’d have to hold for a couple of months at least. Nope, we can get better than that in gilts or even a decent deposit account. 
So, yes, it’s often enough true that a bid leaves a staging opportunity. It hasn’t this time with Instem. Ah well, at least we know that we should spend our money and attention elsewhere.