Rite Aid (NYSE: RAD) stock dropped 51% on Friday. RAD stock dropped as the WSJ reported that the company was preparing for Chapter 11. Assuming the filing does go ahead it’s not clear that the equity will have any value. It’s not just the current debt load, it’s the potential growth in it as those opioid lawsuits come down the pike at it. The real issue, in law, is whether the prescriptions it filled for the pills were legal prescriptions. If so then it’s got a defence. If not then not so much. But the way that American liability law actually works is that, well, let’s not try standing too much upon trivialities like evidence and facts.
As the WSJ points out: “The chapter 11 filing would cover Rite Aid’s more than $3.3 billion debt load and pending legal allegations that it oversupplied prescription painkillers, the people said. Philadelphia-based Rite Aid hasn’t agreed on a settlement with federal, state government and private opioid plaintiffs to resolve those opioid liabilities in a potential chapter 11 and is currently planning to treat them as general unsecured claims, they said.” That means the opioid payments, even when agreed, would rank behind the current secured debt. And of course equity is behind even those opioid numbers. So, whether there’s a value to Rite Aid stock depends near purely on the outcome of those suits.
Rite Aid stock price from Google Finance
As we’ve pointed out before about another company, Mallinckrodt: “Mallinckrodt (NYSE: MNK) stock jumped 435% one Friday a couple of weeks back. On the idea that perhaps something clever could be done about that payment it has to make into the opiates settlement just coming up. On the other hand, as the WSJ reported, perhaps it won't be able to do something clever and will declare bankruptcy once again. It's even possible that the treat of doing that is the clever thing to be done. For while a Chapter 11 bankruptcy would almost certainly preserve the necessary payments into the settlement fund it's not obvious that such flows of funds would be privileged in a Chapter 7. And while privileged not necessarily fully preserved in a Chapter 11. “ We updated on Mallinckrodt as well.
Once these companies are tied up into these opiates cases that’s near the entire determinant of their value. The claims are larger than any capital value they’ve got. So, into Chapter 11 they do and try to sort out priority and payment under the auspices of the court. Well, OK, but that also pretty much wipes out the equity - that Chapter 11. Just the way it works.