Gem Diamonds (LON: GEMD) shares are down 5% on the announcement of their trading results. That GEMD shares are down isn’t all that much of a surprise - Gemfields was telling us of diamond market problems earlier. If we’ve two companies in the same industry - even if they’re mining in different places - then yes, we would expect them to suffer from the same market conditions. Even to the point that we might use the first to report to tell us about the second.
The results from Gem Diamonds: “During the Period increasing grid electricity interruptions caused a reduction in volumes of ore processed.” Now it’s true that they’re mining in Lesotho. But the power grid is intimately connected with that of South Africa - which is in a terrible state as we know. And unless something fairly substantial is done and soon that’s only going to get worse. But it’s this that matters: “The global rough diamond market has experienced a downturn in 2023. A decrease in the number of large, high-value diamonds recovered, combined with market pressure has negatively impacted the average dollar per carat and revenue achieved during the Period.” Sure, there’s an element of chance in finding a decent sized gemstone, in finding something nicely coloured and so on. But total carats produced is directly related to ore processed. It’s the price per carat that then matters for revenue and profitability. And it’s that price that’s under pressure.
Gem Diamonds share price from Google Finance
We looked at this before when we discussed Gemfields: “There is always though that worry about how sustainable this is. Partly simply fashion, will emeralds - as opposed to rubies just as an example - remain the stone that people want? Given that the valuations here are always and only about conspicuous consumption then it does matter how fashions go in conspicuous consumption.
Not to have too much of a downer on it the diamond industry is an example. Prices per carat have been falling. Partly this is to do with artificial, lab grown, diamonds getting much better. There's no particular technical reason why lab grown emeralds shouldn't do the same at some point. Or rubies for that matter. It's also true that fashions have changed - that diamond engagement ring is no longer the simple default.”
Yes, we know, emeralds are not the same as diamonds. But both are luxury, Veblen, goods and so both can and should be compared on that basis. Prices are off in such markets as they react to the economic cycle.