ITM Power (LON: ITM) (OTCPK: ITMPF) shares are up 3% this morning. ITM shares rose on the announcement of the results. Which are indeed slightly better than previously expected. “Revenue of £5.2m (FY22: £5.6m) significantly ahead of guidance of £2m Adjusted EBITDA loss of £94.2m (FY22: £39.8m)* in line with the £85m to £95m guidance Net cash at the year end of £283m (FY22: £366m) ahead of guidance of £245m to £270m”
But note that they’re only slightly better than expected this the rather muted change in the share price in response.
The big issue for ITM Power is that at the moment that revenue is near nothing but the development costs are very high. Well, OK, that’s the sort of thing that happens with developing a new technology like fuel cells. We’re all fine with that. But then comes the big question - is the new technology going to sell well? Or is it all going to get bypassed by some other tech? And sadly we will only actually know that once it has all happened. We can guess at the future but we cannot forecast it. So there’s still considerable risk here - will the tech roll out into the mass market or not?
ITM Power share price from Google Finance
This is why one of London’s most shorted stocks is this very ITM Power: “ITM Power (LON: ITM) shares are the most shorted stock in London at present. Given the 75% fall in price over the past 12 months already that is showing a certain optimism in the short case for ITM. But then that's what the market is calling and that's therefore the consensus view. As investors or traders our duty is to try and work out what we want to do about this. Do we agree with the standard view or differ?”
The reason why is that very risk at ITM: “The ITM share problem is that the company is pretty much a binary play here. There's a very good argument that they're in the right place, the right technology in the middle of a boom for the sector. There's also the argument that they're ever so fractionally off being right and are therefore going to end up doing perhaps nothing, or near nothing. So, ITM Power could be worth much more than it is - or much less. That's what we mean by the binary position here. If matters continue as they are then it's not worth that current price but then, well, are matters going to so continue?”
The current results don;t really tell us very much about that binary choice - is the tech going to roll out to hte mass market or isn’t it?