VinFast Auto (NASDAQ: VFS) overpriced IPO but how much higher will it go?

VinFast Auto (NASDAQ: VFS) stock is up 90% on the day of its IPO. The VFS stock price performance is more impressive than that of course, it’s rather more like 350% because it really started at the $10 SPAC price. This is not a rational price, not rational at all - this makes the small Vietnamese EV maker worth more than Ford, GM or Stellantis. The market capitalisation is, at $85 billion, substantially more than any one of those three and approaching that of any two of them.

Now, there is a way that we can reach that sort of number. Which is that the switch to EVs entirely opens up the car market. Everything that the three majors owns - the factories, the union agreements, the dealership networks - becomes a cost, a liability, and the new market entrants are able to race to market domination. And yes, everyone laughed when Telsa said that’s exactly what they were going to do and now look at it. But that is what the current VinFast Auto valuation is insisting. That this is going to happen once again. Also, that all the value of it going to happen should already be incorporated into the current stock price. We’d suggest that that’s an over valuation.

VinFast Auto

VinFast Auto stock price from Seeking Alpha

It’s also possible to approach this another way, which is to look at the shareholding structure: “VinFast’s billionaire founder Pham Nhat Vuong owns about 99 per cent of its shares, leaving only a small amount available for trading. Only 1.3mn shares of the Spac were able to be traded after earlier redemptions and just $185mn in shares changed hands, according to analysts.” Ah. So while we’ve that heady $85 billion valuation we’ve really only got modest trade in an extremely limited float - that 1% of total valuation being on the market.

We would very strongly suggest that this price is going to turn. The problem is, of course, knowing when it’s going to turn. We’d insist that this price is irrational. But as JM Keynes pointed out, the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain liquid.

We don’t think this is going to last: “Billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong, Vietnam’s wealthiest man, joined the top ranks of Asia’s richest after shares of his electric vehicle maker VinFast Auto surged 255% on the company's Nasdaq debut, adding a whopping $39 billion to his net worth. The stock jumped more than threefold to close at $37.06 on its first trading day, off an intraday high of $38.77. The strong market debut boosted the net worth of Vuong, VinFast's controlling shareholder, to $44.5 billion.” While we insist that it isn’t we agree that we don’t know where it’s going to go between now and a more rational price. And we’d be very worried indeed about attempting to short something in such a tight - and irrational - market.