Renascor Resources (ASX: RNU) (OTCPK: RSNUF) shares are down 22%. RNU shares dropped on the presentation of the Siviour Battery Anode project plans. Which is a bit odd as that report shows that it’s value creating, profitable and they’ve even already got much of the finance to be getting along with. All of those are things we’d like to see in a plan so the idea that the shares become worth less upon its presentation is odd. But then even before this latest Renascor had lost some 40% from its peak. The world just seems less interested in graphite than it used to be. Or, to mention one of our favourite theories, perhaps there’s something else going on here?
The announcement itself: ““The study results confirm Renascor’s BAM Project as a low-cost, high-value supplier of 100% Australian-made graphite for the growing lithium-ion battery anode sector. By integrating the world class Siviour Graphite Deposit with an in-country downstream manufacturing facility, the BAM Study provides a clear path to creating a competitive advantage as a low-cost producer of Purified Spherical Graphite.
The project has already attracted conditional funding support from the Australian Government and non-binding commitments from leading anode manufacturers.” And, well, OK. There’s nothing in that report that looks particularly odd or out of place. There is a preference for natural graphite over synthetic in battery anodes. The world is going to be having many more batteries. There is substantial new natural graphite mining coming through but local production has a value too.
So the decline, well, one explanation is just that everyone thought that the results would be even better than this. This makes some sense in junior miners - the valuation is always heavily dependent upon hopium and so when the real news arrives there can be some deflation. Thus that old stock market mantra of buy the rumour, sell the fact.
Renascor Resources share price from Google Finance
However, it’s also possibl;e to get a little more sophisticated, as we did with Sayona Mining: “At which point that odd little theory. That there’s a cycle to investors in mining companies. At the exploration stage - with junior miners looking for, but not producing, the metal or mineral - the shareholding register is dominated by speculators. People moving in and out as rumours swirl about what might be found and so on. They’re there for the excitement, for the possible capital gains. Well, OK - and for a mature miner there’s very little of such excitement. The arrival of the definitive feasibility study tells us how much there is to be mined, once production starts there aren’t really any great surprises likely. Which means that the speculators lose interest and move off to the next generation of juniors. What should then happen is that the long term investors arrive. Those looking for steady share prices and dividends - the earnings from the mining. But, and here’s the theory, the speculators leave before the investors arrive. Thus there’s a cycle here. A low point after production starts in a mine. Once actual profits start to be announced then the investors turn up and the share price rises again.”
Now, if that’s true then Renascor could be a buy in the near future. Being just ahead of the investors after the speculators have left would be a good idea. But do note that not everyone buys into that idea. For the obvious reason that if everyone agreed with it then the opportunity wouldn’t exist as people would all trade on it. As so often stock market theories that actually work depend upon the majority of people not believing them.