Solvar (ASX: SVR) shares dropped 36% this morning on the back of a feeble profit prediction for the coming year. SVR shares are hit by one of the standard problems that affects non-bank lenders. Not being a bank and competing with banks is indeed a problem at times. This is a little different from Adam Smith’s observation about the basic banking problem - which is that lending money isn’t the problem, it’s finding people worth lending to who are. Solvar is lending secured (auto loans) and while the economy is clearly slowing they’re not predicting any major rise in defaults. So, that’s not the problem they’ve got - it’s the other non-bank problem that’s affecting them, the cost of funds.
The announcement from Solvar: “FY24 NPAT will be impacted by the full year cost of central banks rate rise cycle. Increases in funding costs are being passed through on new loans written, however it reduces the profit contribution from the back book. After adjusting for this, with EBITDA expected to remain consistent with FY23, the Group anticipates a full-year normalised NPAT of $24m-$30m. Management expects profitability to exceed historical levels beyond FY24, as we continue to maintain and expand yield on new loan originations.”
That’s the heart of it at least. As ever, reading corporate releases is an art, not a science. The fun stuff is usually toward the end. So, the beginning here is things are going great, the last part is “So great that profits will fall”. And yes, it is because they’re a non-bank lender.
Solvar share price from Google Finance
A bank gains some goodly part of its finance from the float. This is the amount that washes through our current accounts. The bank doesn’t pay us interest (or vanishingly small amounts if it does) on this, but it is able to agglomerate it and then lend it out. This is rather the point of fractional reserve banking. So, as interest rates rise then the interest margin rises for a bank. They’re able to lend out at ever higher rates and yet on that goodly portion of their funding they’re still paying nothing. Lovely jubbly for bankers then.
Non-bankers don’t get this. They’re always borrowing from the markets. Which is fine - but that does mean they have to pay market interest rates. So that net margin gap doesn’t rise as interest rates do. Further, as Solvar points out, the old book of loans already issued now has to be financed at the new, higher, market rates while the price being charged to borrowers is term fixed. So they actually get margin compression with higher rates. That’s just the difference between banks and non-banks as interest rates rise.
There’s no solution to this, it’s just something that has to be suffered.